News
 
Varghese Summersett

Challenging the Intoxilyzer 9000: How to Fight DWI Breath Test in Texas

The rise in DWI cases across Texas has brought increased scrutiny to the state’s primary breath testing instrument, the Intoxilyzer 9000. While prosecutors often present breath test results as ironclad evidence, several critical vulnerabilities exist that create compelling opportunities for challenge. This article explores the most significant issues with Texas’ implementation of the Intoxilyzer 9000 and how these weaknesses can impact DWI cases.

Texas Breath Alcohol Testing Regulations and Oversight

Texas has a long history of regulating breath alcohol testing procedures. Texas initiated breath alcohol testing in the late 1940s, but statewide implementation began in 1968 with the Breathalyzer. The program gained statutory authority through the 1969 Implied Consent Law, which empowered the Department of Public Safety to establish and oversee breath testing protocols. In 1969, the Texas Legislature established the Texas Breath Alcohol Testing Regulations . To administer and enforce these regulations, the Texas Department of Public Safety created the Office of the Scientific Director. This office oversees all evidential breath analyses conducted by state, county, and city law enforcement agencies. The current legal framework defines intoxication in Chapter 49 of the Texas Penal Code using two distinct standards: loss of normal mental or physical faculties, or an alcohol concentration of 0.08 or greater (measured as grams of alcohol per 210 liters of breath).

Currently, these tests are performed in over 370 approved facilities in Texas by approximately 6,000 certified breath test operators, representing around 700 different law enforcement agencies. These operators must follow strict protocols to ensure the reliability of the results.

Fight DWI Breath Test in Texas

The Role of the Scientific Director and Technical Supervisors

The Scientific Director approves and certifies all breath alcohol testing instruments used in Texas for evidential purposes. A list of approved instruments is kept, and any new or modified instruments are evaluated by the Scientific Director before being accepted.

Technical Supervisors are qualified forensic scientists certified by the Scientific Director. They serve as the Scientific Director’s representatives in all matters related to breath alcohol testing. Their main duties include providing technical, administrative, and supervisory expertise to protect the scientific integrity of Texas’ breath alcohol testing program. Technical Supervisors, who must possess a baccalaureate degree in chemistry or related science, oversee operations in their assigned areas.

Breath Test Operators are individuals certified by the Scientific Director to conduct evidential breath alcohol analyses for law enforcement. The Office of the Scientific Director has created detailed training standards and curricula for operator certification. Operator certification requires initial training, regular renewal, and maintenance of proficiency through ongoing testing. Notably, operators must complete any combination of five subject or practice tests between certification periods and undergo biennial instruction with written examination.

Approval Criteria for Evidential Instruments

According to the regulations, all evidential breath testing instruments in Texas must meet specific criteria, including:

  • Analyzing expired breath specimens accurately.
  • Using a reference system with results that agree within ±0.01 g/210L of the stated value (or other limits set by the Scientific Director).
  • Ensuring the procedure’s specificity is sufficient to accurately measure alcohol concentration in a law enforcement setting.
  • Successfully passing any additional tests deemed necessary by the Scientific Director to ensure correct, reliable results for law enforcement purposes.

Once an instrument meets these requirements, it is placed on the Scientific Director’s approved list. However, approval can be rescinded for cause if the instrument no longer meets the necessary standards. Technical Supervisors are tasked with confirming that a specific instrument’s serial number matches one on the approved list and that it continues to meet the certification criteria. If issues arise, the Scientific Director or a designated representative can remove the instrument from evidential testing.

fight your breath test in texas

Intoxilyzer 9000 in Texas

The Intoxilyzer 9000 operates on the principle of infrared spectrometry. This technology measures alcohol concentration by analyzing how ethanol molecules absorb infrared energy at specific wavelengths. The instrument’s use of multiple wavelengths ensures specificity for ethyl alcohol, distinguishing it from other substances that might be present in breath samples. The system includes calibration verification processes, requiring results between 0.070 and 0.090 g/210L for accuracy validation.

Operational Protocols and Critical Requirements

Several critical protocols govern the proper operation of the Intoxilyzer 9000. Perhaps most crucial is the mandatory 15-minute observation period before testing, during which a certified operator must continuously monitor the subject to ensure no substances enter the mouth. This waiting period prevents contamination from residual mouth alcohol, which could skew results.

The testing sequence follows a strict protocol including:

  • Operational system checks
  • Air blank analyses
  • Multiple subject breath samples
  • Calibration verifications
  • Solution temperature monitoring

Issues that Can Compromise Intoxilyzer 9000 Results

Several issues can compromise test validity or operator certification. These include:

  1. Failure to maintain proper observation during the 15-minute waiting period
  2. Calibration verification results outside acceptable ranges
  3. Reference sample temperatures beyond the 33.8°C – 34.2°C specification
  4. Operator certification lapses due to missed renewal deadlines
  5. Interference from substances like acetone in diabetic subjects

When protocols are not followed, consequences can be significant. Tests may be invalidated, and operators may face certification suspension for a minimum of 30 days. Critically, the presence of interfering substances requires immediate test termination, and subjects cannot be retested under such circumstances.

operation of the intoxilyzer 9000

The Missing Histogram: A Critical Gap in Scientific Validation

Perhaps the most glaring issue with Texas’ deployment of the Intoxilyzer 9000 is the state’s deliberate decision to forego the histogram function. This isn’t just a minor feature omission—it represents the absence of a crucial scientific safeguard that other states consider essential for validating breath test results.

Why the Histogram Matters

The histogram function provides real-time graphical data of breath samples, offering vital information about breath flow rate, volume patterns, and alcohol concentration throughout the sample. This visual representation serves as a quality control mechanism, allowing technicians to spot irregular breathing patterns, detect mouth alcohol contamination, and verify proper sample collection. Without this feature, Texas law enforcement lacks a key tool for ensuring the accuracy and reliability of breath test results.

In other jurisdictions, such as Florida, courts rejected breath test evidence when Intoxilyzer 8000 machines showed airflow issues leading to incorrect results. Some states even banned breath test evidence until proper verification features were installed. Texas’ choice to operate without this critical verification mechanism raises serious doubts about the scientific reliability of its breath testing program.

Infrared Detection Limitations

The shift to measuring carbon-oxygen (C-O) vibrations in the 9-micron region, rather than carbon-hydrogen (C-H) bonds at 3 microns, introduces new complications in breath analysis. This fundamental change in detection methodology creates several potential problems:

The device can be affected by multiple common substances that share similar molecular structures:

  • Dimethyl Sulfoxide (DMSO), commonly used in medical treatments
  • Diethyl ether, present in many industrial solvents
  • Various esters used in food flavoring
  • Industrial chemicals with similar molecular bonds

COVID-19’s Lasting Impact on Reliability

The COVID-19 pandemic added another layer of complexity to breath testing reliability in Texas. Before April 2020, the Department of Public Safety required monthly in-person inspections, regular calibration checks, and physical verification of testing environments. When these requirements were suspended during the pandemic, however, many counties never fully returned to their previous protocols.

Maintenance Gaps Under the Kelly Standard

This deviation from standard maintenance procedures poses major legal vulnerabilities under the Kelly standard, which requires prosecutors to prove the validity of the underlying scientific theory and its proper application. Without consistent in-person maintenance, questions arise about whether breath testing is being applied correctly and in line with scientific principles.

Physical inspections and calibration checks are vital for establishing that a machine is in proper working order—an essential requirement for admitting scientific evidence. When these steps are skipped or done remotely, it opens the door to legal challenges, ranging from basic hearsay objections to confrontation clause issues under Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts.

challenging the intox 9000

Scientific Reliability and Quality Control

Beyond procedural flaws, the combination of missing features and reduced maintenance raises broader concerns about scientific reliability. Proper scientific practice demands controls, verification steps, and thorough documentation to confirm accurate results. Texas’ Intoxilyzer 9000 program lacks many of these safeguards.

Without the histogram function, technicians cannot confirm proper breath sample collection or detect contaminants like mouth alcohol. Reduced in-person maintenance further increases the risk that errors or malfunctions might go unnoticed for long stretches of time.

Building an Effective Challenge Strategy

Challenging breath test evidence effectively requires addressing both technical and legal weaknesses. Defense attorneys should seek out complete maintenance records, particularly for the periods when maintenance procedures were altered. Comparing pre-COVID and post-COVID protocols can uncover significant differences in quality control.

Cross-examining technical supervisors is also crucial. By asking detailed questions about their knowledge of machine condition, how remote inspections were conducted, and the basis for declaring the machine in good working order, attorneys can expose gaps in the foundation for breath test evidence. These gaps support various legal challenges, from Kelly reliability to constitutional violations.

The Future of Breath Testing in Texas

As DWI cases continue to rise, questions about the Intoxilyzer 9000’s accuracy may push Texas to revisit its breath testing procedures. The interaction between limited verification features and scaled-back maintenance has created risks that courts may no longer be willing to overlook.

This situation also prompts larger questions about balancing law enforcement goals with scientific reliability. While breath testing is important for public safety, the current Texas system seems to favor convenience over accuracy. Omitting key verification features and reducing maintenance threatens the integrity of criminal prosecutions.

Our criminal defense attorneys stand between you and the government

Conclusion

These concerns over Texas’ Intoxilyzer 9000 go far beyond small technical details—they challenge the core of scientific reliability and constitutional rights in DWI cases. Missing features like the histogram function and scaled-back maintenance during COVID-19 create powerful reasons to doubt the breath test’s accuracy.

Defense attorneys who understand these issues have a solid opportunity to challenge the admission of breath test results. By highlighting how the Intoxilyzer 9000 falls short of accepted scientific standards and legal requirements, they can protect their clients’ rights and push for needed reforms.

Ultimately, these challenges could prompt Texas to adopt more rigorous verification tools and stricter maintenance protocols for breath testing instruments. Until then, recognizing and leveraging these vulnerabilities remains critical for ensuring justice in DWI cases.

Tough cases call for the toughest lawyers.

Read More:

The New York Times: These Machines Can Put You in Jail. Don’t Trust Them.

Learn More About Our Related Practice Areas

Dallas Criminal Defense
Fort Worth Criminal Defense
Fort Bend Criminal Defense
Collin County Criminal Defense
Houston Criminal Defense

Learn more about our DWI Defense

Dallas DWI Defense
Fort Worth DWI Defense
Fort Bend DWI Defense
Collin County DWI Defense
Houston DWI Defense

Varghese Summersett

There are two types of crash reports in Texas: the Driver’s Crash Report (CR-2) for self-reported accidents or the Peace Officer’s Crash Report (CR-3) completed by law enforcement.

While the CR-2 uses plain language anyone can understand, the CR-3 employs various codes to document vehicle damage, injuries, and contributing factors that require additional information to interpret. The CR-3 includes three-part damage codes (showing impact direction, location, and severity), specialized damage classifications, and standardized codes for a variety of fields including for injuries and contributing factors.

Understanding these codes is crucial since the CR-3 serves as the official accident record used by insurance companies, lawyers, and courts to determine fault and process claims. This guide will break down the coding systems used in the Texas and help you read a Texas crash report.

Understanding Texas Crash Reports

In this guide, our Texas personal injury lawyer takes a closer look at the Texas Peace Officer’s Crash Report (Form CR-3), break down each section, and explain how you can use it to your advantage.

What is a Texas Crash Report?

A Texas crash report documents a broad range of information, such as:

  • Vehicle damage
  • Injuries and fatalities
  • Road and weather conditions
  • Contributing factors (like speeding or mechanical failures)

The official version of this document is known as Form CR-3, which was last updated in 2023 by the Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT). The CR-3 form is used statewide to ensure uniform data collection and reporting across Texas. For accidents not investigated by law enforcement, drivers may complete Form CR-2, known as the Driver’s Crash Report when a crash results in injury, death, or apparent property damage of at least $1,000. This is filed with the local police department and is not maintained by TXDOT. As of 2017, it is not a requirement for drivers to complete a CR-2, although it is widely used for other requirements by insurance companies.

Video: How to Read a Texas Crash Report

When is a Crash Report Required?

In Texas, pursuant to Transportation Code 550.062 , filing a crash report is legally required if:

  1. The crash results in injury or death of any person,
  2. Property damage from the crash is $1,000 or more, or
  3. Law enforcement officers are dispatched to the scene.

This requirement ensures that a detailed, official record exists whenever a crash causes significant harm or damage. The information in the report can become essential if you need to file an insurance claim or become involved in a legal dispute.

The CR-3 Form at a Glance

The CR-3 form is organized into multiple sections designed to capture every aspect of the crash:

  1. Basic Crash Information
  2. Vehicle and Driver Information
  3. Injury Information
  4. Damage Assessments
  5. Contributing Factors
  6. Narrative and Diagram

We’ll explore each section in detail.

1. Basic Crash Information

At the very beginning, you’ll see fundamental facts about the crash:

  • Date and time of the crash
  • Exact location (city, county, street, or highway markers)
  • Weather and road conditions (rain, fog, pavement conditions)
  • Whether the crash occurred in a construction zone or involved hit-and-run scenarios

These details set the stage for the rest of the report, highlighting when and where the crash took place, as well as any environmental factors that may have played a role.

Texas crash report with codes

2. Vehicle and Driver Information

Each vehicle involved gets its own subsection. You’ll find:

  • Vehicle Identification Number (VIN), make, and model
  • Driver’s license information and contact details for each driver
  • Insurance details, including the policy number and insurer
  • Damage specifics for each vehicle

This section ensures law enforcement has identified everyone involved, including passengers and other relevant parties.

3. Injury Information

If someone was injured or killed, the report will note:

  • The nature and severity of injuries
  • Whether the injured individual was taken to a hospital
  • Injury classification codes, such as:
  • K – Fatal injury
  • A – Incapacitating injury
  • B – Non-incapacitating injury
  • C – Possible injury
  • N – No injury

These codes help insurance companies, lawyers, and investigators quickly assess the overall severity of the crash.

top texas car accident lawyer

4. Damage Assessments

One of the more complex parts of the crash report is the damage rating system. Three main components describe the impact on each vehicle:

  1. Direction of Force (XX)
    Uses a clock face analogy (1–12) to indicate the primary direction of the collision. Example: “12” means a front impact; “3” means impact from the right side.
  2. Damage Description (ABC)
    Uses letter codes like FC (Front Concentrated) or LP (Left Passenger area) to indicate precisely where the vehicle was hit and how damage was spread.
  3. Damage Severity (Y)
    A scale from 0 to 7, where 0 is no damage and 7 is severe or total destruction. Example: “12-FC-3” means a front impact (12 o’clock), focused damage to the front end (FC), with moderate severity (3).

You may also see Special Damage Codes like VB-1 (vehicle burned not due to collision) or TP-0 (top damage only). These give unique details about specific or unusual types of damage.

5. Contributing Factors

Crashes often have multiple causes, and this section lists the officer’s interpretation of what went wrong. Examples include:

  • Driver inattention or distraction
  • Speeding
  • Following too closely
  • Failure to yield
  • Unsafe lane changes
  • Mechanical failures (like bad brakes)
  • Road design issues

These factors can be crucial in determining who might be at fault and whether the road or a vehicle had safety issues.

We are lawyers who level the playing field. Don't give the other side an unfair advantage.

6. Narrative and Diagram

Here, the investigating officer offers a written summary of the crash. Often, the officer will describe:

  • How the vehicles were traveling before the collision
  • Maneuvers attempted (e.g., turning left, changing lanes)
  • Environmental conditions (e.g., heavy rain, slick roads)

Alongside the narrative, you’ll see a diagram showing how the officer believes the crash unfolded. Arrows, labeled vehicle units, and direction indicators help visualize the sequence of events.

How to Obtain a Copy of a Texas Crash Report

You can generally get a copy of your crash report through one of these methods:

  1. Online via TxDOT’s Crash Report Online Purchase System
    Visit the TxDOT website and look for the “Crash Reports and Records” section. Enter your details (like the date of the crash and the location) to search for your report. Pay the required fee, which is usually around $6.00 for a regular copy.
  2. Mail Request to TxDOT
    Complete a CR-91 form (Application for Copy of Peace Officer’s Crash Report) or provide a written request. Include payment and key crash details. Mail everything to TxDOT’s mailing address listed on their site.
  3. Contact the Law Enforcement Agency Directly
    Many police departments keep their own records. Call or visit in person to submit a records request, depending on that department’s procedures.

It may take a couple of weeks for a report to appear in the TxDOT database, so don’t worry if you can’t find it immediately.

injured we can help

Related Documents: CR-2 (Blue Form) vs. CR-3

You may come across references to a “CR-2” or “Blue Form.” This is a Driver’s Crash Report that individuals fill out themselves when law enforcement doesn’t complete an official CR-3 form at the scene. The CR-2 is not considered an official law enforcement report—rather, it’s a self-reported document that may or may not be used by insurance companies.

By contrast, the CR-3 (Peace Officer’s Crash Report) is the official law enforcement record of the crash, containing the officer’s findings and professional assessment.

How Crash Reports Are Used

  • Insurance Claims
    Insurance adjusters use crash reports to assess vehicle damage, determine fault, and calculate claim payouts.
  • Legal Proceedings
    If you hire an attorney or go to court, the crash report is often used as evidence. While it’s not the final word on liability, it’s an important record.
  • Personal Record-Keeping
    Having an official document outlining the incident can help you remember details if issues arise down the road (e.g., delayed injuries or additional property damage).

Special Considerations

  • Hit-and-Run
    Officers might include extra details, such as descriptions of the fleeing vehicle, suspect information, or witness statements.
  • Multiple Vehicle Crashes
    Each vehicle is assigned a unit number. Pay close attention to these numbers in the narrative and diagram to follow the sequence of collisions.
  • Commercial Vehicle Crashes
    These crashes may have extra data (like special license endorsements or hazardous materials details). Commercial crashes often involve more regulations, so the officer’s notes here may be more detailed.

Correcting Errors or Disputing the Report

If you find errors or discrepancies in your Texas crash report, consult your attorney immediately. Whether it’s a CR-2 Driver’s Report or CR-3 Peace Officer’s Report, your lawyer can review the documentation for accuracy and protect your interests.

This is especially important with CR-3 reports, where officers make assessments based only on information available at the crash scene. Your attorney can gather additional evidence like surveillance footage or witness statements that weren’t initially available, and when warranted, work to have supplemental reports issued that reflect new evidence.

Time is critical – delays in disputing report contents can affect credibility in both insurance claims and legal proceedings. Since officer reports inform both insurance determinations and potential legal matters, having your attorney review any discrepancies helps ensure your interests are properly protected.

Key Takeaways

  1. Know the Sections: The CR-3 is divided into clear parts—basic info, vehicles, injuries, damage codes, contributing factors, and a narrative/diagram.
  2. Understand the Codes: Direction of force, damage descriptions, and severity ratings help visualize how the crash happened.
  3. Use It Wisely: This document is a valuable tool for insurance claims, legal cases, and personal records.
  4. Double-Check Details: Mistakes in basic info can cause major headaches down the road.

Conclusion

Deciphering a Texas crash report may seem overwhelming at first, but once you understand how each section works, the document becomes much more approachable. The CR-3 form is designed to standardize and simplify the reporting process—allowing law enforcement, insurance companies, and individuals involved in a crash to rely on consistent information.

By taking the time to review and verify the details, you’ll gain a clear picture of what happened and be better prepared to handle insurance claims, legal disputes, or any future questions about the incident. If you ever feel lost, remember that you can reach out to the investigating agency, your insurance provider, or an attorney to make sure you fully understand your rights and responsibilities.

Varghese Summersett

Over 50 people gathered on December 19 for a ribbon-cutting ceremony at Varghese Summersett’s Houston office to celebrate the firm’s expansion to a fourth location.

The law firm, which has offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, and Southlake, opened its newest office on the eighth floor of a modern, 12-story building at 2925 Briarpark Drive, located in the Westchase business community of West Houston.

The expansion allows the firm to provide comprehensive legal services to clients across Harris and Fort Bend Counties, including Houston, Pasadena, Sugar Land, Pearland, Richmond, and surrounding areas.

Varghese Summersett Celebrates Houston Location with Ribbon-Cutting Ceremony

“This is another significant milestone for Varghese Summersett,” said Managing Partner Benson Varghese.  “We’re thrilled to expand our reach to one of Texas’ most dynamic regions and help more people navigate life’s most difficult challenges. We look forward to positively impacting this community for decades to come.”

The firm’s Houston grand opening was sponsored, in part, by the Houston West of Chamber of Commerce . Guests enjoyed mimosas and hors d’oeuvres by MyLeigh’s as they toured the beautiful new space.

“Expanding Varghese Summersett’s presence into Harris and Fort Bend Counties is an incredible opportunity,” said Senior Counsel Mike Hanson, who leads the firm’s Houston-area operations.  “This is my home, and I’m deeply committed to the people and communities here. I am proud to bring the firm’s reputation for excellence, integrity, and white-glove service to the Houston area.”

Varghese Summersett Celebrates Houston Location with Ribbon-Cutting Ceremony

About Varghese Summersett

Varghese Summersett is a premiere criminal defense , personal injury, and family law practice in Texas dedicated to helping people through life’s greatest challenges. The firm is headquartered in downtown Fort Worth, but has locations in Dallas, Southlake, and Houston. The firm boasts a highly experienced team of award-winning attorneys committed to providing exceptional legal services.

Varghese Summersett has more than a thousand 5-star Google reviews and has been named a fastest-growing company by Inc. 5000. It has also been named a “DFW Favorite,” a “Best Place to Work,” and a “Best Place for Working Parents,” among numerous other accolades.

Varghese Summersett Expands to Houston

Varghese Summersett

Being involved in a car accident can be overwhelming,especially when it’s through no fault of your own. In Texas, which operates under an at-fault system, determine who caused the accident isn’t just about assigning blame; it directly affects who pays for medical bills, property damage and other losses.

In this article, the personal injury attorneys at Varghese Summersett explain what ‘at-fault accidents’ mean for Texas drivers and outline the steps you should take after being injured in a collision.

Texas Is an At-Fault Accident State: What That Means for Drivers

What is an At-Fault Accident State?

Texas operates under an at-fault accident system, which means the driver responsible for causing an accident is also responsible for the resulting damages. This includes medical bills, property damage, lost wages, and pain and suffering. In at-fault states like Texas, California, and Georgia, the victim has the right to seek compensation from the at-fault driver or their insurance company.

This system stands in contrast to no-fault states like Florida, Michigan, and New York, where each driver’s insurance pays for their own damages regardless of fault. Understanding this distinction is critical because fault determines liability in Texas car accidents.

If you’ve been injured in an at-fault state, building a strong case to establish the other driver’s negligence is essential to securing fair recovery.

comparative-negligence-in-texas.jpg

Indications a Driver is At-Fault

Determining fault in a vehicle accident often comes down to identifying negligence or a failure to follow traffic laws. Here are some typical indications that a driver may be at fault:

Traffic Violations

  • Running a red light or stop sign
  • Speeding or driving too fast for road conditions
  • Failing to yield the right of way
  • Improper lane changes or unsafe merging

Distracted Driving

  • Texting, talking on the phone, or using in-car technology
  • Eating, drinking, or engaging in other distractions behind the wheel
  • Failing to pay attention to surrounding traffic or road conditions
  • Following too closely (Tailgating)
  • Rear-end collisions often indicate that the following driver did not maintain a safe distance to stop in time
  • Evidence of alcohol or drug use, such as failed sobriety tests, can establish fault

Reckless or Aggressive Driving:

  • Excessive speeding, weaving between lanes, or ignoring traffic signals
  • Road rage behaviors that endanger others
  • Failure to maintain control
  • Losing control of a vehicle due to negligence, such as driving too fast on wet roads or overcorrecting, may point to driver fault.
  • Worn brakes, malfunctioning lights, or bald tires that contribute to the accident

By identifying these indications, insurance companies, legal professionals, and courts can determine who is liable for an accident. If you’ve been involved in a crash and suspect another driver is at fault, gathering evidence such as photos, reports, and witness information is critical to proving your case.

How is fault proven in texas car accident

How Is Fault Proven in a Texas Car Accident?

Fault in Texas car accidents is determined through evidence and investigation. Determining fault involves several key factors:

  • Police Reports: Law enforcement officers responding to the scene document observations, take statements, and may assign fault in their official report. While the report itself is not conclusive in court, it plays a significant role in insurance claims and settlement negotiations.
  • Witness Statements: Neutral third-party witnesses can provide invaluable insight into how the accident occurred. Their testimony can corroborate or dispute each driver’s account.
  • Physical Evidence: Skid marks, vehicle damage, traffic camera footage, photographs, and other physical evidence help reconstruct the sequence of events leading to the crash.
  • Driver Apologizes: If a driver apologizes or admits to being distracted or negligent at the scene, this can be used as evidence of responsibility.
  • Comparative Negligence: Texas law applies a modified comparative negligence rule (discussed further below), which means fault can be shared among multiple parties. Hiring an attorney can ensure a thorough investigation of the evidence to build a strong case for compensation.

Difference between at-fault and no-fault states

The Difference Between an At-Fault Accident State and No-Fault States

In at-fault states like Texas:

  • The driver responsible for the accident pays for the victim’s damages through their insurance.
  • Victims have the option to file a claim with the at-fault driver’s insurance, file a personal injury lawsuit, or claim under their own insurance (depending on coverage).

In no-fault states:

  • Each driver’s insurance pays for their own damages, regardless of who caused the accident.
  • Legal action against the at-fault party is typically limited unless serious injuries occur.

The Texas at-fault system gives victims greater flexibility but requires clear proof of fault to recover damages.

Common Misconceptions About At-Fault Accident States

  • “The at-fault driver always pays out of pocket.”
    In most cases, their insurance pays, unless damages exceed coverage limits.
  • “Fault is always clear-cut.”
    Determining fault often involves disputes and investigations.
  • “You can’t file a lawsuit.”
    In Texas, victims can pursue legal action when necessary.

Advantages and Challenges of an At-Fault System

Advantages

  • Accountability: Drivers are held responsible for their actions.
  • Compensation Options: Victims can file claims directly with the at-fault driver’s insurance, pursue a lawsuit, or rely on their own coverage.

Challenges

  • Disputes Over Fault: Insurance companies often dispute liability to avoid paying claims.
  • Underinsured Drivers: Many drivers carry minimum coverage, which may not be sufficient for major accidents.

Navigating these challenges can be overwhelming without legal assistance.

Texas Is an At-Fault Accident State: What That Means for Drivers

Insurance Requirements in an At-Fault Accident State

Texas law mandates that all drivers carry minimum liability insurance to cover damages they cause in an accident. These requirements, under the state’s minimum liability insurance requirements, are:

  • $30,000 for bodily injury per person
  • $60,000 for total bodily injury per accident
  • $25,000 for property damage

This is often referred to as 30/60/25 coverage. Drivers who fail to maintain insurance face penalties, including fines, license suspension, and vehicle impoundment.

However, minimum coverage may not be enough in accidents involving severe injuries or substantial property damage. In such cases, the at-fault driver may be personally liable for damages exceeding their policy limits.

comparative-negligence-in-texas.jpg

What If I’m Partly at Fault? Comparative Negligence in Texas

If you believe you may be partially responsible for an accident, it’s important to understand how Texas law handles shared fault. Texas follows a modified comparative negligence rule under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §33.001 . Here’s how it works:

You can recover damages only if you are 51% or less at fault for the accident. If you are partially at fault, your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault.

For example, If your damages total $100,000 but you are found 20% at fault, you can recover $80,000. If you are 51% or more at fault, you cannot recover any damages.

This rule highlights the importance of building a strong case to demonstrate the other party’s fault and minimize your percentage of liability. An experienced personal injury attorney can gather evidence, consult with experts, and negotiate on your behalf to ensure your level of fault is accurately represented—maximizing the compensation you deserve.

Will insurance go up for an at-fault accident

Will Insurance Go Up if You’re At-Fault for an Accident?

Yes, your car insurance premium will likely increase if you’re found at fault for an accident. Insurance companies calculate premiums based on risk, and being at fault signals a higher likelihood of future claims. The amount of the increase depends on several factors, including the severity of the accident, the cost of the claim, your driving history, and your insurance provider’s policies.

If it’s your first at-fault accident and you have a clean driving record, some insurers may offer accident forgiveness, which prevents your premium from increasing. However, if you’ve had multiple accidents or traffic violations, the impact on your premium could be more significant.

Steps to Take after an Accident in an At-Fault State

If you’re injured in an accident in Texas through no fault of your own, it’s imperative to take the following steps and strengthen your claim:

  1. Always Carry Adequate Insurance: Texas law requires drivers to carry liability insurance, but not all drivers comply or have sufficient coverage. To protect yourself, consider adding uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage to your policy. This can help cover your expenses if the at-fault driver lacks adequate insurance.
  2. Report the Accident: Notify law enforcement immediately, even for minor accidents. A police report is a critical piece of evidence that can help establish fault. Exchange contact and insurance information with the other driver, but avoid admitting fault or making speculative statements about the accident.
  3. Document the Scene: Collect as much evidence as possible at the scene of the accident:
    * Take detailed photos of the vehicles, damage, injuries, and road conditions.
    * Gather witness contact information and statements. Witnesses can provide impartial accounts of what happened.
    * Note important details, such as time, location, and weather conditions.
  4. Seek Medical Attention: Even if you feel fine, seek medical attention as soon as possible. Some injuries, like whiplash or internal trauma, may not present symptoms immediately. A prompt medical evaluation creates a record of your injuries, which is essential for proving your case.
  5. Contact a Personal Injury Attorney: Navigating the aftermath of an accident in an at-fault state like Texas can be challenging, especially when insurance companies are involved. They may dispute liability or attempt to minimize your payout. An experienced personal injury attorney will:
    * Investigate the accident and gather evidence to prove fault.
    * Handle communications and negotiations with insurance companies.
    * Advocate on your behalf to ensure you receive fair compensation for medical bills, lost wages, property damage, and pain and suffering.

By taking these steps promptly, you not only protect your health but also strengthen your case to secure the compensation you deserve. If you’ve been injured due to another driver’s negligence, contacting a trusted personal injury attorney can make all the difference in achieving a successful outcome.

When to Consider a Personal Injury Lawsuit

When to Consider Filing a Personal Injury Lawsuit Against an At-Fault Driver

In many personal injury cases, insurance claims are resolved through negotiations, but there are situations where filing a lawsuit becomes necessary to protect your rights and secure fair compensation. You should consider pursuing a personal injury lawsuit if:

  • The Insurance Company Denies Liability
    If the at-fault driver’s insurance company refuses to accept responsibility for the accident, they may deny your claim entirely. This often happens when liability is disputed, or the insurer attempts to blame you for the accident. Filing a lawsuit allows you to present evidence, challenge their denial, and hold the responsible party accountable.
  • The Settlement Offer Is Insufficient to Cover Your Losses
    Insurance companies often try to settle quickly for far less than what your case is worth. If the settlement offer does not adequately cover your medical expenses, property damage, lost wages, and other losses, filing a lawsuit can force the insurer to reconsider and may lead to a higher payout through negotiations or trial.
  • You Suffered Severe Injuries
    Serious injuries often require long-term medical treatment, rehabilitation, or even lifelong care. Additionally, these injuries may impact your ability to work, significantly affecting your livelihood. Filing a lawsuit allows you to pursue compensation not just for current expenses but also for future medical costs, lost earning capacity, and ongoing care needs.
  • You Are Entitled to Non-Economic Damages
    Texas law allows injured individuals to seek compensation for non-economic damages—such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and mental anguish. Insurance companies often undervalue these damages, making it necessary to file a lawsuit to ensure you receive the full compensation you deserve.
  • The Statute of Limitations Is Approaching
    In Texas, you generally have two years from the date of the accident to file a personal injury lawsuit. If negotiations with the insurance company stall or remain unproductive, filing a lawsuit ensures you don’t lose your right to pursue compensation under the law.

Filing a personal injury lawsuit may seem daunting, but it is often the most effective way to secure justice and full financial recovery. By working with an experienced personal injury attorney, you can level the playing field, navigate the complexities of the legal process, and fight back against insurance companies that fail to treat you fairly. At Varghese Summersett, we are committed to advocating for our clients every step of the way—ensuring you receive the compensation you need to move forward.

Hire our personal injury attorneys who do not settle for less.

Why Having an Experienced Personal Injury Attorney Matters

When you’re involved in an accident, navigating the legal and insurance processes can be overwhelming, especially while trying to recover physically and emotionally. This is where an experienced personal injury attorney becomes invaluable. Here’s why:

  • Thorough Investigation to Prove Fault
    Determining who is at fault is critical to securing compensation. An experienced attorney will conduct a comprehensive investigation, gather evidence such as police reports, witness statements, and accident reconstructions, and consult with experts when necessary to build a strong case that clearly establishes liability.
  • Skilled Negotiation with Insurance Companies
    Insurance companies often try to minimize payouts, offering settlements that are far below what you deserve. A seasoned personal injury attorney knows how to counter these tactics, leveraging their experience to negotiate effectively and ensure you receive fair compensation for medical expenses, property damage, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
  • Representation in Court When Necessary
    While many personal injury claims are resolved through settlement, some cases require litigation. If a fair agreement cannot be reached, a skilled attorney will represent you in court, presenting a compelling case before a judge or jury to fight for the compensation you deserve.

At Varghese Summersett, our team of dedicated personal injury attorneys has the experience, resources, and tenacity to take on insurance companies and ensure you receive the maximum recovery you’re entitled to. We understand what’s at stake and are committed to standing by your side every step of the way—so you can focus on healing while we focus on winning.

Injured in an Accident? Contact Varghese Summersett Today

If you’ve been injured in a Texas car accident, don’t wait to seek legal help. Evidence can disappear, and delays may jeopardize your case. At Varghese Summersett, we understand the challenges you face and are committed to fighting for the compensation you deserve.

Call us today at (817) 203-2220 or contact us online to schedule a free consultation. Let us handle the legal complexities so you can focus on healing.

injured we can help

Varghese Summersett

Going through a divorce is difficult enough without worrying about your personal information becoming public record. While Texas courts generally keep divorce records open to the public, there are ways to protect your privacy by sealing these records. In this article, we answer, “Can a Divorce Be Sealed in Texas?

The Underlying Framework

Texas courts start with a simple premise: court records should be public. But they also recognize that sometimes privacy is necessary. Generally, to seal your divorce records, you’ll need to prove you have a compelling reason that outweighs the public’s right to know. Think of it like tipping a scale – your privacy concerns need to be heavy enough to outweigh the public interest. [Pro tip: find out why the rich and famous in Texas often get collaborative divorces . The reason will likely surprise you.]

However, when it comes to divorce records, things are a little more nuanced – and relaxed. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 76a(1), all court records are presumed to be open to the general public. However, Rule 76a(2)(a)(3) specifically excludes documents filed in Family Code actions from the definition of “court records.” This means divorce records can be sealed without following Rule 76a’s strict procedural requirements.

Instead of using Rule 76a’s sealing procedure, parties in divorce cases can file a motion for a protective order to limit public access to their records, as established in General Tire, Inc. v. Kepple , 970 S.W.2d 520, 525 (Tex.1998). The court then has the discretion to seal these records under existing law, as specified by Rule 76a(9).

This means divorcing parties have a simpler path to sealing sensitive documents than litigants in other civil cases, though they still need to demonstrate a legitimate reason for restricting public access.

We measure our success by yours

When Can a Divorce Record Be Sealed in Texas?

Texas courts understand that divorce records often contain sensitive information that deserves protection. Unlike other civil cases, divorce records have a special status under Texas law that makes sealing them more straightforward. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 76a(2)(a)(3), documents filed in divorce cases are specifically exempted from the standard strict sealing requirements that apply to other court records.

Protecting Children’s Information

When children are involved, courts take special care in considering what information should remain private. Details about where children live, their schools, or medical information can often be protected through a protective order. Courts recognize that children’s privacy interests deserve particular attention during divorce proceedings.

Business Information Courts Often Protect

Consider a high-level tech executive’s divorce case where filings contain details about unreleased products, confidential partnership negotiations, and internal financial projections. Rather than having to meet Rule 76a’s strict “specific, serious and substantial interest” standard, the executive can seek a protective order to safeguard this sensitive information. Courts routinely consider protecting trade secrets, confidential operations details, and sensitive financial data that could harm a business if made public.

The Practical Approach

While you’ll still need to demonstrate legitimate reasons for sealing records, the process focuses on practical business privacy concerns rather than Rule 76a’s more demanding requirements. For instance, if your divorce filings contain information about upcoming mergers, proprietary technology, or strategic planning documents, a court can issue a protective order to maintain business confidentiality without requiring the extensive procedural steps of Rule 76a.

Safety Concerns

Personal safety concerns are paramount in divorce cases. If you’re dealing with a history of domestic violence or need to keep your new address private from an abusive former spouse, the court can issue a protective order to seal this sensitive information. The process doesn’t require meeting Rule 76a’s strict standards – instead, the court focuses on practical safety needs.

Courts take safety concerns seriously, especially when there’s:

  • A history of domestic violence
  • Active protective orders
  • Credible threats
  • Details about security measures

marriage is difficult

Medical and Mental Health Information

Courts also recognize the sensitive nature of medical and mental health information in divorce proceedings. Whether your case involves mental health evaluations, medical diagnoses, or substance abuse treatment records, you can seek protection of this private information through a motion for protective order. The goal is to maintain necessary medical privacy while still proceeding with your divorce.

Courts often protect records containing:

  • Medical diagnoses and treatments
  • Mental health evaluations
  • Substance abuse treatment information
  • Therapy records

The Process

To protect sensitive personal information or safety-related details, you’ll need to file a motion for protective order that specifically identifies what information needs protection and why. Unlike Rule 76a’s complex requirements, this process focuses on demonstrating legitimate privacy or safety concerns to the court. Your motion should clearly explain the specific information you need to protect and the reasons why protection is necessary.

Our top divorce lawyers help you divorce with dignity.

How to Seal Divorce Records in Texas: The Legal Process

The Texas Family Code and Rules of Civil Procedure provide a specific framework for protecting sensitive information in divorce cases. Under Rule 76a(2)(a)(3), divorce records are exempt from standard sealing requirements, allowing parties to seek protection through a motion for protective order as established in General Tire, Inc. v. Kepple, 970 S.W.2d 520 (Tex. 1998).

Filing Your Motion

Under the Texas Family Code, you’ll need to file a motion for protective order specifically identifying what information you want to protect and why. This motion doesn’t require the extensive procedural requirements of Rule 76a. Instead, you’ll need to demonstrate good cause for protecting the information under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 192.6, which governs protective orders.

Emergency Protection

In cases involving immediate safety concerns, Texas courts can issue temporary orders under Texas Family Code § 6.501 to protect sensitive information while your motion for protective order is pending. These temporary orders can include provisions protecting confidential information or sensitive details that need immediate protection.

Required Evidence

Texas Rule of Evidence 104(a) requires you to demonstrate to the court why protection is necessary. You can present evidence through:

  • Affidavits under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 199.6
  • Live testimony at the hearing
  • Documentary evidence showing the need for protection

Protective Orders

Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 192.6(b), the court can issue a protective order if it finds good cause exists to protect the information. Unlike Rule 76a’s requirement of “specific, serious and substantial interest,” the good cause standard gives courts more flexibility to protect sensitive information in family law cases.
An experienced family law attorney can help ensure your motion complies with these specific Texas legal requirements while effectively protecting your private information during divorce proceedings.

Our lawyers make sure that every ending is a new beginning.

Varghese Summersett

With holiday shopping in full swing, stores have stocked their shelves with the latest and greatest gifts—but they attract more than eager buyers. This time of year sees a surge in “flash mob thefts,” where groups of individuals descend on stores in coordinated efforts, overwhelming security and staff to steal high-value merchandise and vanish within minutes. Far from random acts of desperation, these are calculated moves by well-organized criminal enterprises.

This phenomenon has a name: Organized Retail Theft, or ORT. It’s a growing concern for law enforcement in Texas, especially during the holiday season when stores are bustling, and resources are stretched thin.

In this article, the criminal defense attorneys at Varghese Summersett break down the laws surrounding Organized Retail Theft in Texas, the potential penalties, and the possible defense for those accused of these crimes.

What is Organized Retail Theft in Texas?

Organized Retail Theft (ORT) is a coordinated crime involving individuals or groups who steal merchandise from retail establishments with the intent to resell the goods for profit. Unlike shoplifting, which is typically committed by a single individual for personal use, Organized Retail Theft involves a criminal network that often targets multiple stores, stealing large quantities of merchandise. These goods are then sold through fencing operations, online marketplaces, or other illicit channels.

The state estimates that it loses more than $421 million a year from organized retail theft. And major metropolitan areas, like Houston, rank among the top cities in the United States for Organized Retail Theft, underscoring the popularity of this growing crime.

If you or a loved one is facing a charge of ORT in Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, or the surrounding areas, it is critical to contact a seasoned defense attorney immediately. The attorneys at Varghese Summersett have extensive experience handling complex criminal cases, including Organized Retail Theft.

Texas Law

The Law: Organized Retail Theft in Texas

Under Section 31.16 of the Texas Penal Code , a person commits Organized Retail Theft if he or she intentionally conducts, promotes, or facilitates an activity where a person receives, possesses, conceals, stores, barters, sells, or disposes of:

  1. stolen retail merchandise; or
  2. merchandise explicitly represented to the person as being stolen retail merchandise.

This statute differentiates Organized Retail Theft from standard theft by focusing on the organized and coordinated nature of the nature of the crime. Key elements of Organized Retail Theft in Texas include:

  • Collaboration between multiple individuals to commit theft.
  • Targeting retail establishments to steal merchandise.
  • Selling stolen goods through established fencing operations or online platforms.

What is Organized Retail Theft in Texas?

The Punishment for Organized Retail Theft in Texas

The penalties for Organized Retail Theft in Texas depend on the total value of the stolen merchandise. These penalties range from misdemeanors to first-degree felonies, as outlined below:

  • Less than $100: Class C misdemeanor punishable by up to a $500 fine.
  • $100 to $749: Class B misdemeanor punishable by up to 180 days in jail.
  • $750 to $2,499: Class A misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail.
  • $2,500 to $29,999: State jail felony punishable by six months to two years in a state jail facility.
  • $30,000 to $149,999: Third-degree felony punishable by 2 to 10 years in prison.
  • $150,000 to $299,999: Second-degree felony punishable by 2 to 20 years in prison.
  • $300,000 or more: First-degree felony punishable from 5 years to life in prison.

Certain aggravating factors can increase the charges to a higher level. For example:

  • Acting as a leader within the theft ring.
  • Activating or deactivating fire exit alarms during the theft.
  • Using tools or devices to circumvent anti-theft measures.

In addition to state prosecution, Organized Retail Theft cases may also be pursued at the federal level if they involve interstate operations or large-scale theft.

Collateral Consequences

Collateral Consequences of Organized Retail Theft in Texas

A conviction for Organized Retail Theft (ORT) in Texas extends far beyond fines, probation, or jail time—it can significantly impact your personal and professional life for years to come. Because ORT is considered a crime of moral turpitude, the consequences can ripple through nearly every aspect of an individual’s future. Here’s a closer look at the potential fallout:

  • Damage to Reputation and Employability
    A conviction for Organized Retail Theft can permanently tarnish your reputation. Crimes of moral turpitude—offenses that involve dishonesty or deceit—carry a social stigma that can raise red flags for employers. Many companies conduct background checks, and an ORT conviction may make it difficult to secure jobs, especially in industries that require trust, such as retail, finance, or education.
  • Loss of Professional Licenses
    For individuals in licensed professions—such as nursing, law, real estate, or teaching—an Organized Retail Theft conviction can lead to disciplinary actions or even the loss of their license. Licensing boards often view crimes of dishonesty as a breach of professional ethics, which can jeopardize a person’s ability to work in their chosen field.
  • Difficulty Securing Housing and Financial Aid
    A criminal record can also create challenges in obtaining housing or financial aid. Landlords and housing authorities frequently screen applicants for criminal convictions, and a conviction for a theft-related crime can result in denials. Additionally, federal financial aid for education may be restricted for individuals with certain types of criminal records.
  • Civil Lawsuits
    Retail establishments that have suffered losses due to Organized Retail Theft may pursue civil lawsuits to recover damages. These lawsuits can include restitution claims for the stolen merchandise, legal fees, and other related costs, further compounding the financial burden on the accused.
  • Immigration Consequences
    For non-U.S. citizens, a conviction for Organized Retail Theft as a crime of moral turpitude can have serious immigration consequences, including denial of naturalization, visa revocation, or deportation.

Given these far-reaching consequences, it’s essential to take ORT charges seriously and seek experienced legal representation. A strong defense may help reduce the charges, avoid a conviction, or mitigate the penalties, protecting your future from the collateral damage of an ORT conviction.

Money Laundering

The Roles in Organized Retail Theft

Organized Retail Theft (ORT) is a sophisticated criminal operation that involves multiple participants, each playing a distinct role to ensure the success of the enterprise. These roles are integral to the functioning of ORT networks, and understanding them is key to combating this form of organized crime. Here’s an in-depth look at the primary roles:

Boosters

Boosters are the frontline operatives who physically steal merchandise from retail stores. They often work in teams, employing tactics such as distraction, concealment, or speed to evade detection. Boosters are typically highly skilled at navigating store layouts and exploiting vulnerabilities in security systems. Their stolen goods fuel the supply chain of the ORT operation.

Fences

Fences act as intermediaries between boosters and the end market. They purchase stolen goods from boosters at a fraction of their retail value and resell them for profit. Fences may operate through physical storefronts, online marketplaces, or informal networks. Their role is crucial in converting stolen merchandise into liquid assets, which finance the broader criminal enterprise.

Cleaners

Cleaners are responsible for “sanitizing” stolen goods by removing security tags, labels, or any other identifying markers that could trace the merchandise back to the theft. This process makes the items more marketable and reduces the risk of detection during resale. Cleaners may also repackage goods to make them appear new or untraceable.

Money Launderers

Money laundering is an essential component of Organized Retail Theft operations, as it disguises the illegal origins of profits generated by selling stolen goods. Money launderers use various techniques, such as creating fake businesses, mixing illicit funds with legitimate revenue, or using offshore accounts, to obscure the money trail. Their role ensures that the financial gains can be safely reinvested into the operation or enjoyed by the ringleaders.

Ringleaders

Ringleaders are the masterminds behind the Organized Retail Theft operation. They recruit and coordinate the efforts of boosters, fences, cleaners, and money launderers, ensuring the enterprise operates smoothly and profitably. Ringleaders often reap the largest financial rewards while staying insulated from the day-to-day risks. They use their organizational skills and connections to maintain control over the network, plan large-scale thefts, and expand their criminal enterprises.

Each of these roles is critical to the success of an organized retail theft operation, creating a well-oiled machine that exploits weaknesses in retail systems for profit.

Organized retail theft in Texas

Examples of Organized Retail Theft in Texas

Organized Retail Theft (ORT) manifests in various ways, often involving sophisticated planning and execution. Below are some real-world examples that illustrate the scope and methods used in these crimes:

Large-Scale Theft Across Multiple Retail Locations

In one scenario, a group systematically targeted major electronics stores across Houston, stealing high-value items such as laptops, tablets, and gaming consoles. By hitting multiple locations in a single day, the group amassed merchandise worth tens of thousands of dollars. The thefts were coordinated, with individuals assigned specific roles, such as distracting employees, grabbing items, or driving getaway vehicles.

Fencing Operations Through Online Platforms

Another common example involves the sale of stolen goods through online marketplaces. High-end fashion items, electronics, or jewelry are listed on e-commerce platforms such as auction sites or social media marketplaces, often at discounted prices to attract unsuspecting buyers. These platforms provide anonymity and a global reach, making it difficult for law enforcement and retailers to trace the stolen goods back to their origins.

Warehouse Storage of Stolen Merchandise

Sophisticated crime rings often use storage units, warehouses, or even rented homes as hubs to conceal large quantities of stolen goods. For instance, a Texas-based operation rented multiple storage units to store stolen merchandise collected from different cities. Once a significant inventory was gathered, the items were sold in bulk to buyers who knowingly or unknowingly participated in the illegal resale process.

“Smash-and-Grab” Thefts

In some cases, groups execute dramatic smash-and-grab thefts, breaking into retail stores after hours or using tools to shatter display cases. These incidents often target jewelry stores, electronics retailers, or high-end fashion boutiques. The stolen goods are quickly removed, and the perpetrators flee within minutes, making it challenging for authorities to respond in time.

Retail Employee Involvement

Organized theft rings sometimes recruit employees to assist with their schemes. These individuals may provide inside information about store layouts, schedules, or security weaknesses, making the thefts more effective. In some cases, employees are coerced or incentivized to participate in return for a share of the profits.

These examples highlight the diverse tactics and ingenuity behind Organized Retail Theft in Texas, as well as the significant challenges they pose for retailers and law enforcement.

being proactive in criminal defense

What to Do if Arrested for Organized Retail Theft in Texas

If you are arrested for Organized Retail Theft in Texas:

  • Remain silent: Do not speak to law enforcement without legal counsel.
  • Preserve evidence: Gather any documentation, receipts, or communication that could support your case.
  • Contact Varghese Summersett immediately: Time is critical to building an effective defense.

Possible Defenses for Organized Retail Theft in Texas

Defenses for a charge of Organized Retail Theft in Texas depend on the circumstances of the case but may include:

  • Lack of intent: Demonstrating that the accused did not knowingly participate in the theft or resale of stolen merchandise.
  • Mistaken identity: Proving that the accused was wrongly identified as part of the theft ring.
  • Lack of evidence: Highlighting insufficient evidence to connect the accused to the organized activity.
  • Coercion or duress: Showing that the accused was forced to participate against their will.

An experienced criminal defense attorney will thoroughly investigate the case to identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s argument and build a strong defense.

Facing a Charge of Organized Retail Theft in Fort Worth, Houston, or Dallas? Contact Us Today.

Organized Retail Theft is a serious offense with far-reaching consequences. If you or a loved one is facing charges, call Varghese Summersett at 817-203-2220 or contact us online for a confidential consultation. Our attorneys have a deep understanding of Texas theft laws and the experience necessary to protect your rights.

Tough cases call for the toughest lawyers.

Varghese Summersett

Should You Get an Attorney After a Car Accident in Texas?

If you’ve recently been in a car accident, you may be wondering whether you should hire an attorney to handle your claim. The answer depends on the specifics of your case, but in many situations, hiring an attorney can help you recover more and get back on your feet faster — even after accounting for their fees. This guide explains when you don’t need an attorney and when it is essential to have a personal injury lawyer after a car accident in Texas. We’ll also cover how hiring a lawyer for a car accident benefits you in ways that extend beyond just financial recovery.

when should you not hire a personal injury lawyer

When You Probably Don’t Need a Lawyer After a Car Accident

In some scenarios, hiring an attorney may not be worth the time, effort, or cost. Here’s when it’s typically unnecessary:

1. If There Is Only Property Damage

If your car accident resulted in property damage only — for instance, damage to your vehicle or other personal belongings — and no one was injured, you likely don’t need to hire an attorney.

Texas is an at-fault state, meaning the party responsible for the accident (and their insurance company) pays for the damages. Property damage claims are generally straightforward and can be resolved directly with the at-fault driver’s insurance company. As long as liability is clear and the insurance company is cooperating, you can handle these claims yourself.

How to Handle a Property Damage Claim:

  • Document the Damage: Take photos of your vehicle and any other property that was damaged.
  • Get an Estimate: Obtain repair estimates from reputable mechanics or body shops.
  • Contact the Insurance Company: File a claim with the at-fault driver’s insurer and provide all necessary documentation.
  • Negotiate If Needed: If the insurer offers less than the repair costs, you can negotiate without legal representation.

2. If You Were At Fault or Mostly At Fault

If you were entirely or mostly at fault for the accident, hiring an attorney is typically unnecessary unless the other party is filing a lawsuit against you. Texas follows a modified comparative fault rule, which means:

  • If you are 51% or more at fault , you cannot recover any compensation.
  • If you are 50% or less at fault, you can recover damages, but they will be reduced by your percentage of fault.

For example, if you were 30% at fault and sustained $10,000 in damages, you would only be eligible to recover $7,000. However, if you were 51% or more responsible, you would not be eligible for any compensation. In such cases, your best course of action is to let your insurance company handle the matter.

when should you hire a personal injury lawyer

When You Should Hire an Attorney After a Car Accident

While there are situations where hiring an attorney isn’t necessary, there are also circumstances where having legal representation is critical. Here are the key reasons to hire an attorney after a car accident in Texas:

1. If You Were Injured

Personal injuries complicate car accident claims significantly. If you suffered injuries, it’s in your best interest to hire an attorney. Injuries often lead to substantial medical bills, lost wages, and long-term pain and suffering, all of which can be difficult to quantify without legal expertise.

Why Hiring a Lawyer Is Worth It, Even With Legal Fees

Some people hesitate to hire an attorney because they know a percentage of their recovery will go toward legal fees. However, a lawyer’s expertise can result in a much larger settlement or judgment, even after fees are deducted. Here’s why:

  • Better Access to Medical Care: Attorneys often work with medical providers who treat clients on a “lien basis.” This means the providers wait for payment until after the case is resolved. If no recovery is made, you typically won’t owe for the treatment. This allows you to get the care you need without worrying about upfront costs.
  • Negotiating with Insurers: Insurance companies have teams of adjusters trained to minimize payouts. Attorneys know how to counter their tactics, using evidence and legal arguments to demand higher settlements.
  • Maximizing Compensation: An attorney will seek full recovery for all damages, including medical bills, lost wages, future treatment costs, pain and suffering, and emotional distress.
  • Avoiding Costly Mistakes: Handling your own claim can lead to errors, such as accepting a lowball settlement or missing legal deadlines. An attorney protects you from these pitfalls.
  • Peace of Mind: Having an attorney manage your case allows you to focus on recovering physically and emotionally.

2. If You Are Filing on Behalf of Someone Who Died

If you are seeking compensation after the death of a loved one in a car accident, Texas law allows certain family members to file a wrongful death claim. These claims are highly complex and require an experienced attorney to navigate.

Who Can File a Wrongful Death Claim in Texas?

  • Spouse: The surviving spouse of the deceased.
  • Children: Biological or adopted children of the deceased.
  • Parents: Biological or adoptive parents of the deceased.

If none of these individuals file a claim within three months of the death, the deceased person’s executor or personal representative may file the claim on behalf of the estate, unless family members explicitly request otherwise.

Learn more about who can file a wrongful death lawsuit in Texas.

What Can You Recover in a Wrongful Death Claim?

  • Funeral and burial expenses
  • Loss of income the deceased would have earned
  • Loss of companionship, love, and support
  • Mental anguish suffered by surviving family members

our bench is deep

3. If Fault Is Disputed and You Were Injured

When fault for the accident is unclear or disputed, an attorney can be invaluable. Proving liability requires gathering evidence, interviewing witnesses, and sometimes consulting accident reconstruction experts. Without legal representation, you risk losing your claim or being unfairly assigned fault.

How an Attorney Can Help When Fault Is Contested

  • Investigating the Accident: Attorneys can collect police reports, witness statements, and any available video footage.
  • Working with Experts: They may bring in experts to reconstruct the accident or testify about the events leading up to it.
  • Negotiating with Insurers: Insurance companies are more likely to lowball or deny claims when fault is unclear. An attorney can counteract these tactics.

4. If the Insurance Company Undervalues Your Injury Claim

Insurance companies often deny claims or offer settlements far below what you’re entitled to. If this happens, you should hire an attorney to fight for a fair outcome.

Common Insurance Company Tactics:

  • Claiming your injuries aren’t as severe as you state
  • Arguing that your medical treatment was unnecessary or excessive
  • Blaming you for the accident
  • Delaying the claims process to frustrate you into accepting a low offer

An experienced attorney knows how to counter these strategies and negotiate effectively.

injured we can help

Conclusion: Should You Get a Lawyer After a Car Accident?

The decision to hire an attorney after a car accident in Texas depends on your specific circumstances. You probably don’t need an attorney if the accident only caused property damage, or you were at fault. However, if you were injured, fault is disputed, or the accident involved a fatality, hiring an attorney is critical.

An experienced attorney can help maximize your compensation, protect your rights, and ensure you get the care you need. They provide expertise, resources, and advocacy that often lead to better outcomes — even after accounting for their fees. If you’re unsure whether you need an attorney, many law firms, including ours, offer free consultations to help you evaluate your situation. During this consultation, an attorney can review the details of your case, explain your options, and provide guidance on the best path forward. This allows you to make an informed decision without any upfront cost or obligation.

Remember, time is of the essence after an accident. Evidence can fade, memories can become less reliable, and there are legal deadlines to consider. Reaching out to an attorney promptly can make a significant difference in the strength of your case. Call Varghese Summersett today at 817-203-2220.

Varghese Summersett

How Does Modified Comparative Negligence Affect Liability Decisions in Texas?

In Texas, liability in personal injury cases revolves around the concept of fault. Texas follows the principle of modified comparative fault in determining how damages are awarded when multiple parties share responsibility for an accident. This blog explores what modified comparative fault means in Texas, how it compares to other systems in the United States, and how it impacts liability decisions. We’ll also examine where this law is found in the Texas statutes and provide a comparison table of fault models nationwide.

What Is Modified Comparative Negligence?

Modified comparative fault is a legal doctrine that allocates damages based on the percentage of fault assigned to each party involved in an incident. Texas uses a modified comparative fault rule with a “50% bar”. This means:

  • A plaintiff can recover damages only if they are 50% or less at fault for the incident.
  • If the plaintiff is found to be over 50% at fault, they are barred from recovering any damages.

For example, if a jury finds a plaintiff 40% at fault for a car accident and the defendant 60% at fault, the plaintiff can recover 60% of their damages. However, if the plaintiff is 51% at fault, they recover nothing.

Where Is the Modified Comparative Liability Rule Found in Texas Law?

The modified comparative fault rule in Texas is codified in Section 33.001 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code , as part of the Texas Proportionate Responsibility Statute. This statute outlines the rules for assigning fault and calculating damages in civil cases. Sections 33.003 and 33.012 provide additional guidance on how juries allocate fault and reduce damages accordingly.

how does modified comparative affect liability

How Modified Comparative Fault Impacts Liability in Texas

When a personal injury claim goes to trial, a jury determines each party’s percentage of fault. Based on this determination:

  • The plaintiff’s damages are reduced by their percentage of fault.
  • If the plaintiff’s fault exceeds 50%, they cannot recover any damages.

For example, if a plaintiff incurs $100,000 in damages and is found 40% at fault, their recovery will be reduced to $60,000. Conversely, if they are 51% at fault, they recover nothing. This same evaluation is discussed and considered in settling personal injury cases. 

Comparing Fault Models in the United States

The United States employs three primary models for handling shared fault in personal injury cases:

  • Pure Comparative Fault: Plaintiffs can recover damages regardless of their percentage of fault, even if they are 99% at fault. Damages are reduced proportionally to their fault.
  • Modified Comparative Fault: Plaintiffs can recover damages only if their fault is below a specific threshold (usually 50% or 51%).
  • Contributory Negligence: Plaintiffs are barred from recovering any damages if they share any fault for the accident, even as little as 1%.

Comparison of Fault Models

Fault Model Threshold for Recovery States Using This Model
Pure Comparative Fault No threshold; plaintiffs can recover damages even if 99% at fault California, Florida, New York, and others
Modified Comparative Fault (50% Bar) Plaintiffs can recover if their fault is 50% or less Texas, Arkansas, Colorado, and others
Modified Comparative Fault (51% Bar) Plaintiffs can recover if their fault is less than 51% Nebraska, Kansas, and others
Contributory Negligence No recovery if the plaintiff has any fault Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, and others

Key Takeaways for Plaintiffs and Defendants

For Plaintiffs:

In Texas, personal injury attorneys typically won’t take cases where the client is majority at fault. Since attorneys generally work on contingency fees in personal injury cases, they cannot justify investing time and resources into cases where Texas law explicitly bars recovery.

  • Prove the other party’s negligence to minimize your percentage of fault.
  • Understand the 50% threshold; if your fault exceeds 50%, you cannot recover damages.
  • Work with an attorney to build a strong case and reduce your liability.

For Defendants:

For defendants in Texas, this rule is advantageous as they can completely avoid paying damages if they can prove the plaintiff was 51% or more at fault. Even if the defendant is found partially responsible but less than 51%, they only pay their proportional share of the damages.

  • Shift blame to reduce your percentage of responsibility.
  • Focus on showing the plaintiff’s fault exceeds 50% to bar their recovery.
  • Use proportionate responsibility as a negotiation tool in settlements.

Conclusion

Texas’ modified comparative fault system ensures accountability while allowing injured parties to recover damages if their fault is 50% or less. By codifying this rule in Section 33.001 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, the state has established a fair balance between plaintiff and defendant rights.

If you’re involved in a personal injury case in Texas, understanding how fault is allocated can make all the difference. Whether you are seeking compensation or defending against a claim, work with an experienced attorney to navigate the complexities of proportionate responsibility.

Varghese Summersett

When suspicions of infidelity arise in a marriage, it’s natural to want answers – and the urge to spy on your spouse can be strong. However, the methods you use to uncover the truth can have serious legal consequences. Texas law is clear on what is permissible when it comes to surveillance, and violating these laws could result in criminal charges, civil liability, or other repercussions.

In this article, the criminal defense and family law attorneys at Varghese Summersett explain what Texas law allows — and prohibits—when it comes to spying on your spouse. If you suspect your spouse is cheating, it’s more prudent to consult a divorce attorney rather than resorting to potentially illegal measures.
Can You Spy on Your Spouse in Texas if They're Cheating

Spy on Your Spouse: What Texas Law Says

Recording Conversations
Under Texas Penal Code § 16.02 , the Lone Star State is a one-party consent state for recording conversations. This means that it is legal to record a phone or in-person conversation as long as one party consents to the recording.

Examples:

  • Legal Recording: If you are on the phone with your spouse, you can legally record the conversation without their knowledge or consent.
  • Illegal Recording: It is unlawful to secretly record a conversation between your spouse and a third party if you are not a participant in the conversation.

While Texas is a one-party consent state, the decision to spy on your spouse by recording conversations without their knowledge should be approached cautiously to avoid breaking the law.

Taking Photos and Videos in Public Places

Taking Photos and Videos in Public Places

In public spaces, there is generally no reasonable expectation of privacy. You can take photos or videos of your spouse in public without violating the law. However, this does not extend to private settings where privacy is expected.

Examples:

  • Legal: Taking a photo of your spouse meeting someone in a restaurant.
  • Illegal: Secretly recording your spouse in a private setting, such as a bathroom or changing room. This constitutes invasive visual recording under Texas Penal Code § 21.15. Invasive visual recording is a state jail felony punishable by six months to two years in a state jail facility and a maximum $10,000 fine.

If you attempt to spy on your spouse by capturing private moments, you risk severe penalties under Texas law.

Sharing Intimate Photos or Videos Without Consent

Sharing Intimate Photos or Videos Without Consent

Under Texas Penal Code § 21.16, also known as the “Revenge Porn Law,” it is illegal to share intimate photos or videos of another person without their consent. This includes posting such materials on social media or sending them to others without the subject’s knowledge. Violating this law is a state jail felony punishable by up to two years in jail and a maximum $10,000 fine.

Examples:

  • Legal: Sharing intimate photos or videos of yourself or your spouse, provided you are of legal age and both parties consent to the distribution.
  • Illegal: Posting intimate photos or videos of your spouse on social media without their explicit consent.
  • Illegal: Sending intimate photos or videos of your spouse via text, email, or messaging apps without their knowledge or permission.
  •  Illegal: Sharing intimate content that was privately shared with you by your spouse (or any other individual) with others without their consent, even if it was initially shared consensually with you.

Accessing Communications Without Permission

Accessing Communications Without Permission

It is illegal to intercept or access someone’s communications without their consent. This includes opening mail, hacking into emails, or accessing private accounts. Texas Penal Code § 16.04 prohibits the unauthorized interception or use of communications. Violating this law can be penalized as a Class A misdemeanor or a state jail felony.

Examples:

  • Legal: Accessing communications if your spouse has explicitly provided consent, such as sharing login credentials and granting you permission to use their email or account.
  • Legal: Reviewing shared communications in a jointly owned or explicitly shared account where both parties have agreed to mutual access.
  • Illegal: Opening your spouse’s personal email account without permission.
  • Illegal: Intercepting text messages or monitoring phone activity without their consent.

Can You Spy on Your Spouse in Texas if You Suspect Cheating?

Installing Tracking Devices on Vehicles

Installing a GPS tracker on a vehicle your spouse exclusively owns or leases is illegal under Texas law. Texas Penal Code § 16.06 prohibits the unauthorized installation of a tracking device on another person’s vehicle. Illegally installing a tracking device is a Class A misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in jail and a maximum $4,000 fine.

Examples:

  • Legal: Installing a GPS tracker on a vehicle you own or co-own with your spouse.
  • Illegal: Hiding a GPS tracker in your spouse’s car without their consent.

Trying to spy on your spouse by placing a GPS tracker on their vehicle can result in criminal charges if the car is not jointly owned.

Spousal Privacy Rights During Divorce

Recap: Spousal Privacy Rights During Divorce

In today’s digital age, attempting to invade the privacy of a spouse or ex-spouse has become increasingly complex and consequential. In 2023, Texas passed new legislation that significantly strengthens privacy protections in spousal and ex-spousal relationships. This law specifically prohibits:

  • Tracking vehicles or personal belongings of a spouse/ex-spouse without explicit consent;
  • Physically following a spouse/ex-spouse or having someone else do so; and
  • Accessing a spouse’s phone, online accounts, or social media without permission

The law emphasizes the need for “effective consent,” which requires clear and informed agreement from the spouse for any form of tracking. This legislation impacts how evidence can be gathered in divorce and custody cases, potentially making illegally obtained information inadmissible in court.

While Texas remains a one-party consent state for recording conversations, the new law adds additional restrictions on surveillance methods commonly used in suspected infidelity cases. GPS tracking of vehicles, phone monitoring, and social media surveillance without consent are now explicitly illegal.

It’s important to note that there may be some exceptions, such as court-ordered tracking or law enforcement investigations with proper warrants. However, the full implications of this new law, especially regarding private investigators, are still being determined.

Given these recent changes, it’s crucial for individuals suspecting infidelity to consult with a family law attorney before taking any action that could be considered surveillance. Legal methods of gathering evidence, such as reviewing shared financial records, may still be available.

Violating these new privacy laws can result in serious consequences, including criminal charges, civil liability, and negative impacts on divorce proceedings

Cheating Spouse

What to Do if You Suspect Your Spouse is Cheating

If you suspect infidelity, it’s crucial to handle the situation carefully to avoid violating the law. Here’s a step-by-step guide

  • Consult With a Family Lawyer: Before taking any action, speak with an experienced family law attorney. They can advise you on what is legally permissible and help you avoid mistakes that could result in criminal charges or harm your divorce case.
  • Avoid Illegal Surveillance: Do not install a tracking device on your spouse’s vehicle unless you co-own the car.
  • Don’t Access Accounts: Do not access your spouse’s phone or email accounts without their explicit permission.
  • Know the Law about Audio Recordings: Only record conversations if you are a party to the conversation and are within the borders of Texas.
  • Gather Evidence Legally: If you need evidence of infidelity, work with your attorney to obtain it legally by:
    * Hiring a licensed private investigator familiar with Texas laws.
    * Using legally accessible evidence, such as shared financial records that may reveal unusual spending.
    * Consulting a lawyer and adhering to legal guidelines, you can avoid serious consequences while protecting your interests.

Consequences of Spying on Spouse

Potential Consequences of Spying on a Spouse

Engaging in unlawful surveillance can lead to severe repercussions, including:

Criminal Charges

Violating Texas surveillance laws can result in criminal penalties. For example:

  • Installing a GPS tracker without consent may lead to misdemeanor charges.
  • Sharing intimate images without consent could result in felony charges.

Inadmissable Evidence

Evidence obtained illegally—such as unauthorized recordings or hacked emails—cannot be used in court. In fact, attempting to present such evidence could harm your credibility.

Civil Liability

Your spouse could file a civil lawsuit against you for invasion of privacy or other violations. This could lead to significant financial damages.

Restraining Orders

Illegal surveillance may result in your spouse seeking a restraining order against you, which could complicate custody or divorce proceedings.

Contempt of Court

If your actions violate a court order, you could be held in contempt, resulting in fines or jail time.

Before You Spy on Your Spouse: Call Varghese Summersett

Before you decide to spy on your spouse, call Varghese Summersett. Navigating the dissolution of a marriage is stressful enough without the added risk of legal missteps. If you suspect your spouse is cheating, consult with an experienced family lawyer at our firm. We’ll help you understand your rights and guide you through the process while protecting your interests within the bounds of the law. Call us today at (817) 203-2220 or contact us online to schedule a consultation.

helping people through difficult times

Varghese Summersett

Can you fire your personal injury lawyer?

It’s not uncommon for us to get a call from someone who wants to fire their lawyer. Perhaps they’ve found the law firm is slow to respond, or perhaps the lawyer is completely unresponsive. It may be the lawyer hasn’t helped them get into treatment. Or perhaps they have lost faith that the attorney is going to fight for them. Whatever the reason, the question comes up: Can you fire your personal injury attorney?

The answer is “yes,” but there are things you should be aware of before you fire your lawyer in a personal injury case to make sure you are doing it right.

Understanding Your Contract or Letter of Engagement

Most personal injury attorneys in Texas operate on a contingency fee basis, meaning their payment depends entirely on winning your case. This will be laid out in your contract or your letter of engagement with the lawyer. Through a contingency fee arrangement, attorneys typically charge a third of any settlement if your case resolves before litigation begins. However, if your case proceeds to trial, this percentage usually increases to 40 percent to account for the additional work and resources required.

The first thing you want to do is review the letter of engagement to see what claims the attorney will make if you terminate the contract. For example, most contracts will say that the attorney will retain a claim against any recovery even if they are terminated. You will want to pay attention to see if the claim is for their fee (which there they can make under some circumstances) or if it is for case expenses.

Understanding Attorney Liens and Case Expenses

Understanding Attorney Liens and Case Expenses

When an attorney invests time and resources into your case, they may place a lien on any future judgment to ensure compensation for their efforts. This legal mechanism protects attorneys who advance costs on behalf of their clients. These expenses typically include court filing fees, expert witness compensation, investigation costs, and other necessary disbursements that accumulate during your case.

Even if you change attorneys, your original lawyer may maintain this lien to recover their documented expenses and the reasonable value of services provided. This aspect of legal representation often surprises clients, making it essential to understand from the beginning.

Claims for Attorneys Fees (As Opposed to Case Expenses)

You may see that your contract says your attorney will claim attorney’s fees, not just case expenses. You should proceed more cautiously here and make sure you document the termination was for “just cause” here.

The Texas Supreme Court in Mandell & Wright v. Thomas established that if you discharge an attorney hired on a contingency fee basis without good cause before the case concludes, the attorney may seek compensation either through:

  • Quantum meruit: Payment for the reasonable value of services provided.
  • Enforcement of the original contract: Collecting agreed-upon fees from any damages recovered.

Therefore, it’s crucial to have just cause when terminating the relationship to avoid additional financial obligations.

Just Cause for Termination

In Texas, there are several common grounds that justify the termination of an attorney-client relationship for just cause.

The most common reason is a lack of communication. This occurs when an attorney consistently fails to return calls, emails, or messages, does not keep the client informed about important developments in the case, or neglects to provide updates on case progress and next steps.

Neglect of a case is another serious issue. This includes missing important deadlines such as filing necessary documents with the court, failing to attend scheduled hearings or meetings, and not conducting essential investigations or discovery processes. Incompetence or lack of skill can also warrant termination. This is evident when an attorney demonstrates a lack of knowledge about relevant laws or legal procedures or makes significant errors that jeopardize the client’s case.

Breach of fiduciary duty is another valid reason for termination. This happens when an attorney acts in a manner contrary to the client’s best interests or misuses funds or property entrusted to them. Failure to follow instructions is also significant. It involves ignoring the client’s lawful and reasonable directives regarding case strategy or making decisions without the client’s consent that materially affect the case.

These are just a few examples of “just cause” to terminate a lawyer.

template for terminating for just cause

Documenting Just Cause

When considering a change in representation, proper documentation becomes crucial. Keep records of all communication attempts, missed appointments, or other issues that may constitute just cause for termination. This documentation can prove invaluable if fee disputes arise later.

If you are considering terminating your personal injury, be sure you document your reasons why.

Template: Letter to Fire Your Lawyer for Just Cause

For example, if you are terminating your lawyer for just cause based on a lack of communication, your termination letter may look like:

[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[City, TX Zip]

[Date]

VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED

[Attorney Name]
[Law Firm Name]
[Firm Address]
[City, TX Zip]

Re: Termination of Legal Services for Just Cause
[Case Name/Number if applicable]
[Date of Loss: XX/XX/XXXX]

Dear Mr./Ms. [Attorney Last Name]:

I am writing to terminate your legal services effective immediately. This termination is for just cause due to your continued failure to communicate with me about my case. Specifically:

1. You have not returned any of my phone calls on:
• Date and time 1
• Date and time 2
• Date and time 3

2. I have not received any updates about my case since [date], despite multiple requests.

Please immediately provide me with a complete copy of my file. Under Texas law, these files belong to me. Please include all:
– Medical records
– Correspondence
– Investigation materials
– Photos
– Witness statements
– Insurance communications
– Settlement offers
– Pleadings
– Expert reports
– Any other documents related to my case

Please send my complete file to my email: [Email]. You can also mail the case file to me on a USB thumb drive by Certified Mail with a tracking number to my mailing address listed at the top of this letter.

Also provide an itemized list of any expenses you’ve advanced or spent on my behalf. If I do not receive an itemized list of expenses from you in 14 days, I will understand that you are not making any claims for expenses against any future judgment or settlement.

Please confirm receipt of this letter within 48 hours.

Sincerely,

[Your signature]
[Your printed name]

When you decide to change attorneys, a formal termination letter serves as your official notice. This letter should be professional, specific, and sent via certified mail to create a record of delivery. Request your complete case file and an itemized statement of any expenses your attorney claims.

If your case is already in court, additional steps become necessary. Your new attorney must file a “motion for substitution of counsel,” and your former attorney may need to file a “motion to withdraw.” These legal formalities ensure the court recognizes your new representation and maintains proper case management.

Your Rights to Case Files and Documentation

Under Texas law, clients own their case files. This fundamental right means you can request and receive all documents and materials related to your case at any time. Your attorney must promptly comply with such requests, particularly if you decide to seek new representation. This ownership right ensures transparency and helps maintain the balance of power in the attorney-client relationship.

Securing New Representation

While you are going through the process of firing your existing lawyer, you should also be in the process of retaining a new personal injury attorney to assist you with your claim. Interview your prospective lawyer. Make sure you are confident you are not going to run into similar problems. Read their reviews. You might consider setting an appointment to visit with them in person. Let them know you are terminating your current attorney, and why you are doing so. You will want to get your case file from your current attorney and provide it to your new attorney as soon as possible.

Tough cases call for the toughest lawyers.

Protecting Your Interests During Transition

During the transition between attorneys, several key interests need protection. Ensure no deadlines or court dates are missed. Your new attorney should review your case file immediately to identify any upcoming obligations. Your new attorney should also evaluate any liens or claims against your potential recovery. This evaluation helps you understand your financial obligations and ensures the appropriate distribution of any settlement or judgment funds.

Moving Forward with Your Case

After changing attorneys, maintain open communication with your new representation. Discuss any concerns from your previous experience and establish clear expectations for communication and case management.

Remember that changing attorneys shouldn’t significantly delay your case, though some adjustment period is normal as your new attorney reviews your file and develops their strategy. Stay engaged in your case and maintain records of all communications and developments.

Final Considerations

Understanding your rights and responsibilities in the attorney-client relationship empowers you to make informed decisions about your legal representation. Whether working with your original attorney or transitioning to new counsel, clear communication, proper documentation, and knowledge of your rights remain essential to protecting your interests and achieving the best possible outcome in your case.