News
 
Varghese Summersett

Can You File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit After a Drunk Driving Death in Fort Bend County?

Yes. If you lost a loved one to a drunk driver in Fort Bend County, you have the legal right to file a wrongful death lawsuit against the person who killed them. This civil claim is completely separate from any criminal charges the driver may face. Even if the driver is charged with intoxication manslaughter, you can still pursue financial compensation for your family’s devastating loss.

A wrongful death lawsuit allows surviving family members to hold the drunk driver financially accountable. In some cases, you may also have claims against bars, restaurants, or social hosts who served alcohol to the driver before the crash. These civil cases can provide compensation for funeral costs, lost income, and the profound grief of losing someone you love.

We understand that no amount of money can bring back your loved one. But a wrongful death claim can ease the financial burden your family now faces and ensure the person responsible is held accountable beyond what the criminal justice system provides.

If your family is grieving after a drunk driving death in Fort Bend County, our attorneys can help you understand your legal options. Call us today for a free consultation.

The Prosecutor Is Not Your Attorney

The Prosecutor Is Not Your Attorney

This is one of the most important things families need to understand after losing a loved one to a drunk driver. When the Fort Bend County District Attorney’s Office files intoxication manslaughter charges, they are not representing you. They represent the State of Texas.

The prosecutor’s job is to prove the defendant broke the law and to seek punishment on behalf of society. Their goal is a conviction, not compensation for your family. They are not required to consult you about plea deals. They don’t have to take the case to trial if you want them to. They don’t owe you updates or explanations. You are a witness in their case, not their client.

This can feel deeply frustrating. You may want the prosecutor to fight harder, reject a plea offer, or pursue maximum penalties. But you have no control over those decisions. The criminal justice system was designed to punish wrongdoing and protect the public. It was not designed to make victims whole.

What the Criminal Case Cannot Do for You

Even if the drunk driver is convicted of intoxication manslaughter and sentenced to 20 years in prison, the criminal case will not:

  • Pay for your loved one’s funeral
  • Replace the income your family depended on
  • Compensate you for your grief, trauma, or loss of companionship
  • Cover the medical bills from your loved one’s final hours
  • Provide financial security for children who lost a parent

Restitution is sometimes ordered in criminal cases, but it’s limited to direct, documented expenses and is notoriously difficult to collect. It comes nowhere close to the full compensation available through a civil wrongful death lawsuit.

A wrongful death lawsuit is your case. You control it. You decide whether to settle or go to trial. You determine what justice looks like for your family.

Wrongful Death Claims vs. Intoxication Manslaughter Charges

How Is a Wrongful Death Claim Different From Intoxication Manslaughter Charges?

Many families don’t realize that criminal charges and civil lawsuits are two completely different legal processes with different purposes, different standards, and different outcomes.

Criminal Case: The State vs. The Drunk Driver

When a drunk driver kills someone in Texas, the state can file criminal charges for intoxication manslaughter under Texas Penal Code § 49.08 . This is a second-degree felony punishable by 2 to 20 years in prison and fines up to $10,000. The Fort Bend County District Attorney’s Office prosecutes these cases on behalf of the State of Texas, not on behalf of your family.

You have the right to be notified about major developments in the case. You may be asked to provide a victim impact statement. But you don’t get to decide whether charges are filed, what plea offers are made, or whether the case goes to trial. Prosecutors make those decisions based on their assessment of the evidence, their caseload, and their judgment about what serves the public interest.

Civil Case: Your Family vs. The Drunk Driver

A wrongful death lawsuit is your family’s case. You control it. Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 71, surviving family members can sue the drunk driver directly for the harm their actions caused. You hire your own attorney. You decide whether to accept a settlement or go to trial. The goal is compensation for your loss, not punishment for the defendant.

The burden of proof is also different. While prosecutors must prove criminal guilt “beyond a reasonable doubt,” you only need to prove civil liability by a “preponderance of the evidence.” This means showing it’s more likely than not that the driver caused your loved one’s death. This lower standard means families can win wrongful death lawsuits even when criminal cases result in acquittals or reduced charges.

What Must Be Proven in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit

What Must Be Proven in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit?

To win a wrongful death case after a drunk driving crash, your attorney must prove four legal elements. These elements establish that the defendant’s negligence caused your loved one’s death and that your family suffered damages as a result.

Element 1: Duty of Care

The first element requires showing that the defendant owed your loved one a legal duty of care. Every driver on Texas roads has a duty to operate their vehicle safely and follow traffic laws. This includes the duty not to drive while intoxicated. This element is straightforward in drunk driving cases because all motorists owe this duty to everyone else on the road.

Element 2: Breach of Duty

The second element requires proving the defendant breached their duty of care. Driving with a blood alcohol concentration of 0.08% or higher is a breach of the duty to drive safely. So is driving while impaired by alcohol to any degree that affects normal use of mental or physical faculties. Evidence of breach typically includes blood or breath test results, officer observations, field sobriety test performance, witness testimony about the driver’s behavior, and toxicology reports.

Element 3: Causation

The third element requires proving the defendant’s breach of duty caused your loved one’s death. This has two parts. First, you must show “cause in fact,” meaning your loved one would not have died but for the defendant’s intoxicated driving. Second, you must show “proximate cause,” meaning the death was a foreseeable result of driving drunk. In most drunk driving fatality cases, causation is clear. The intoxicated driver caused a crash, and someone died as a result.

Element 4: Damages

The fourth element requires proving your family suffered actual damages because of your loved one’s death. This includes economic damages like funeral expenses, medical bills, and lost income. It also includes non-economic damages like mental anguish, loss of companionship, and loss of guidance. Documenting these damages thoroughly is essential to maximizing your recovery.

How Negligence Per Se Strengthens Your Case

Texas recognizes a legal doctrine called “negligence per se” that can make drunk driving wrongful death cases easier to prove. When a defendant violates a statute designed to protect public safety (like laws against drunk driving), and that violation causes the type of harm the statute was meant to prevent (like a fatal crash), the defendant is presumed negligent.

This means if the drunk driver was arrested with a BAC over 0.08% or was convicted of intoxication manslaughter, you may not need to independently prove they were negligent. Their violation of Texas drunk driving laws establishes negligence as a matter of law. Your attorney still needs to prove causation and damages, but the negligence element is significantly easier to establish.

Who Can File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in Texas

Who Can File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in Texas?

Texas law limits who can bring a wrongful death claim. Under the Texas Wrongful Death Act, only certain family members have the legal right to sue.

Eligible family members include:

  • The surviving spouse of the deceased
  • Children of the deceased (including adopted children)
  • Parents of the deceased

Any of these family members can file a lawsuit individually or together. If no eligible family member files a claim within three months of the death, the executor or administrator of the deceased person’s estate may file on behalf of all eligible family members.

Siblings, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and other relatives generally cannot file wrongful death claims in Texas, even if they were very close to the deceased. This can be heartbreaking for families with non-traditional structures, but these are the boundaries Texas law sets.

When a Child Can Bring a Wrongful Death Claim

What Happens When a Child Has the Right to Bring a Wrongful Death Claim?

When a drunk driver kills a parent, the surviving children have the legal right to file a wrongful death lawsuit. But minor children cannot file lawsuits on their own behalf. Texas law requires an adult to act for them.

How a Minor’s Claim Is Filed

A parent or legal guardian typically files the wrongful death lawsuit on behalf of a minor child. If both parents are deceased, a court-appointed guardian or “next friend” can file the lawsuit for the child. A “next friend” is an adult who acts in the child’s best interest in legal proceedings.

The court closely supervises cases involving minor children to protect their interests. Any settlement must be approved by the court to ensure it’s fair and in the child’s best interest. Settlement funds for minors are typically placed in a trust or structured settlement that the child can access when they reach adulthood.

Special Considerations for Children’s Claims

Children’s wrongful death claims often involve substantial damages because of the long-term impact of losing a parent. A child who loses a mother or father at age 5 will spend decades without parental guidance, support, and love. Courts recognize this when valuing claims for loss of parental consortium.

Texas also has special statute of limitations rules for minors. While adults generally have two years to file a wrongful death claim, a minor’s deadline may be extended. The clock typically doesn’t start running until the child turns 18, though there are exceptions and complications. This protection exists because children cannot be expected to understand or protect their own legal rights.

Our attorneys have represented children who lost parents to drunk drivers. We work with guardians, financial advisors, and the court to ensure minor children receive full compensation and that their funds are protected until they’re old enough to manage them responsibly.

When Multiple Family Members Have Claims

In many drunk driving death cases, multiple family members have the right to file claims. A surviving spouse and children may all have separate claims. Parents of the deceased may also have claims. These claims can be filed together in a single lawsuit or separately.

When minor children and adult family members both have claims, coordination is essential. Our attorneys work to ensure that settlements or verdicts are structured fairly so that children’s interests are protected while also addressing the needs of surviving spouses or other family members.

Wrongful Death Compensation in Fort Bend County

What Compensation Can You Recover in a Fort Bend County Wrongful Death Case?

A wrongful death lawsuit seeks to compensate your family for both the financial and emotional losses caused by your loved one’s death. Texas allows recovery for several types of damages.

Economic Damages

These cover the financial losses your family has suffered and will continue to suffer:

  • Funeral and burial expenses: The costs of laying your loved one to rest
  • Medical bills: Any emergency treatment or hospital care before death
  • Lost earning capacity: The income your loved one would have earned over their lifetime
  • Lost benefits: Health insurance, retirement contributions, and other employment benefits
  • Loss of inheritance: The money or assets you would have inherited if your loved one had lived a full life
  • Loss of services: The value of household tasks, childcare, and other contributions your loved one provided

Non-Economic Damages

These address the emotional and relational losses that are harder to quantify but equally real:

  • Mental anguish: The emotional suffering family members experience
  • Loss of companionship: The relationship, guidance, and presence you’ve lost
  • Loss of consortium: For spouses, the loss of the marital relationship
  • Loss of parental guidance: For children who’ve lost a parent

Exemplary (Punitive) Damages

In drunk driving wrongful death cases, Texas courts may award exemplary damages to punish the defendant for their reckless conduct. Choosing to drive while intoxicated shows a conscious disregard for human life. Courts recognize this and often allow punitive damages to send a message that such behavior will not be tolerated.

Our attorneys represented a Fort Bend County family whose husband and father was killed by a drunk driver with a blood alcohol level nearly twice the legal limit. By documenting the driver’s history of alcohol-related incidents and demonstrating the willful nature of their decision to drive, we secured a settlement that included significant punitive damages, providing meaningful financial security for the widow and her three children.

Can You Sue a Bar or Restaurant for a Drunk Driving Death

Can You Sue a Bar or Restaurant After a Drunk Driving Death?

Yes, in certain circumstances. Texas has what’s called a “Dram Shop” law that allows victims to sue alcohol providers who contributed to a drunk driving crash.

Under Texas Alcoholic Beverage Code § 2.02, you can hold a bar, restaurant, or other alcohol seller liable if they served alcohol to a person who was “obviously intoxicated to the extent that he presented a clear danger to himself and others.” The establishment must have been aware of the intoxication at the time of service.

Fort Bend County has a thriving restaurant and nightlife scene in areas like Sugar Land, Missouri City, and Richmond. When bars and restaurants over-serve patrons who then get behind the wheel and kill someone, they share responsibility for that death.

What You Need to Prove in a Dram Shop Case

Dram shop cases require proving specific elements:

  • The establishment sold or served alcohol to the driver
  • The driver was obviously intoxicated at the time of service
  • The intoxication was a proximate cause of the crash and death

Gathering this evidence requires quick action. Surveillance footage gets deleted. Witnesses’ memories fade. Credit card and bar tab records can disappear. If you believe a bar or restaurant contributed to your loved one’s death, contacting an attorney immediately is essential.

Social Host Liability in Texas

Texas law treats social hosts differently than commercial establishments. Generally, adults who serve alcohol at private parties are not liable if a guest drives drunk and kills someone. There is one major exception: if a host serves alcohol to a minor (someone under 21), and that minor causes a drunk driving death, the host can be held liable under Texas Alcoholic Beverage Code § 2.02(c).

How Long Do You Have to File a Wrongful Death Case in Texas

How Long Do You Have to File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit in Texas?

Texas law gives you two years from the date of your loved one’s death to file a wrongful death lawsuit. This deadline, called the statute of limitations, is strict. If you miss it, you lose your right to sue forever.

Two years might seem like a long time when you’re in the immediate aftermath of losing someone. But between funeral arrangements, dealing with your loved one’s affairs, and trying to help your family cope, time passes quickly. Insurance companies know this. They may delay, hoping you’ll miss your deadline or become too exhausted to fight.

Starting the legal process early also helps preserve evidence. Accident scene conditions change. Vehicles get repaired or scrapped. Witnesses relocate. Phone records and surveillance footage get deleted. The sooner your attorney can begin investigating, the stronger your case will be.

Remember that special rules may apply when minor children have claims. While the statute of limitations for adults is generally two years, minors may have additional time. However, waiting until a child turns 18 to file can make evidence much harder to obtain. The better approach is usually to file promptly with an adult acting on the child’s behalf.

What If the Criminal Case Is Still Pending

What Happens If the Criminal Case Is Still Pending?

You don’t have to wait for the criminal case to finish before filing your wrongful death lawsuit. In fact, there are strategic reasons to move forward with your civil case while the criminal prosecution is ongoing.

Remember, the prosecutor handling the criminal case is not your lawyer. They may make decisions you disagree with. They may accept a plea deal you think is too lenient. They may decline to take the case to trial. Your wrongful death lawsuit gives you an avenue for accountability that doesn’t depend on what the prosecutor decides to do.

That said, many families choose to wait and see what happens in the criminal case first. A criminal conviction can be powerful evidence in your civil lawsuit. If a jury finds the driver guilty of intoxication manslaughter beyond a reasonable doubt, proving civil liability becomes much easier because of the negligence per se doctrine.

The criminal case can also reveal evidence through discovery that helps your civil case. Police reports, toxicology results, witness statements, and accident reconstruction findings from the criminal investigation can all support your wrongful death claim.

Our attorneys can advise you on the best timing strategy for your specific situation. We coordinate with prosecutors when appropriate and monitor the criminal case closely to protect your family’s interests, even though we understand the prosecutor’s priorities may differ from yours.

When the Drunk Driver Has No Insurance or Money

What If the Drunk Driver Has No Money or Insurance?

This is a common concern for families. Winning a wrongful death lawsuit doesn’t help if the defendant can’t pay the judgment. Our attorneys thoroughly investigate all potential sources of recovery before recommending whether to pursue a case.

Potential sources of compensation include:

  • Auto insurance: The driver’s liability coverage, which in Texas must be at least $30,000 per person
  • Umbrella or excess policies: Additional coverage the driver may have
  • Employer liability: If the driver was working at the time of the crash
  • Dram shop claims: Bars and restaurants typically carry significant liability insurance
  • Your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage: Your policy may cover the gap
  • Personal assets: Property, savings, or other assets the driver owns

In one Fort Bend County case, the drunk driver who killed our client’s mother had only minimum insurance coverage. But our investigation revealed he was driving home from a work event where his employer had provided alcohol. We pursued a claim against the employer and recovered substantial compensation that the driver alone could never have paid.

What to Do After Losing a Loved One to a Drunk Driver

What to Do After Losing a Loved One to a Drunk Driver

The weeks and months after losing a family member are overwhelming. While your primary focus should be on grieving and taking care of yourself and your family, there are steps you can take to protect your legal rights.

Preserve Evidence

Keep copies of the police report, any photographs from the scene, and your loved one’s personal effects. Don’t repair or dispose of any damaged property. If your loved one had a phone, preserve it. These items may contain important evidence.

Document Everything

Keep records of all expenses related to your loved one’s death, including medical bills, funeral costs, and time you’ve missed from work. Write down your memories of your relationship and how the loss has affected your daily life. These notes will help your attorney understand the full impact of your loss.

Be Careful What You Say

Insurance adjusters may contact you soon after the crash. They may seem sympathetic, but their job is to minimize what the insurance company pays. Don’t give recorded statements or sign any documents without talking to an attorney first. You’re not required to speak with them, and doing so rarely helps your case.

Understand Your Role in the Criminal Case

You may receive notifications from the Fort Bend County District Attorney’s Office about the criminal case. You may be asked to provide a victim impact statement or testify as a witness. While participating in the criminal process can feel meaningful, remember that the prosecutor represents the state, not you. Their decisions about charges, plea offers, and sentencing recommendations are theirs to make. If you want an attorney who answers to you and fights for your family’s interests specifically, you need to hire a civil attorney to file a wrongful death lawsuit.

Contact an Attorney

A wrongful death attorney can take the legal burden off your shoulders while you focus on healing. We can deal with insurance companies, investigate the crash, and build your case while you take care of your family.

Why Choose Varghese Summersett for Your Wrongful Death Case

Why Varghese Summersett Is the Right Choice for Your Wrongful Death Case

Not every law firm is equipped to handle a wrongful death case after a drunk driving death. These cases require a unique combination of skills: the ability to prove negligence in civil court, deep knowledge of intoxication cases, and the resources to take on insurance companies and go to trial if necessary. At Varghese Summersett, we bring all of this to every case we handle.

Unmatched Experience in Intoxication Cases

Our attorneys have handled more intoxication-related trials than most law firms in Texas. We have spent years in courtrooms across the state proving and defending DWI, DWI with child passenger, intoxication assault, and intoxication manslaughter cases. This experience gives us an intimate understanding of how these cases work, from the science of blood alcohol testing to the procedures police must follow during investigations.

We know what evidence matters in intoxication cases. We understand how to interpret toxicology reports, challenge flawed blood draws, and use accident reconstruction to prove exactly what happened. When we walk into a courtroom or a settlement negotiation, the other side knows we have the knowledge and experience to back up every claim we make.

Former Prosecutors Who Know How to Prove Cases

Several of our attorneys are former prosecutors who spent years on the other side of the courtroom. We didn’t just handle intoxication cases; we tried them. We presented evidence to juries and secured convictions. We know what it takes to prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt, the highest standard in the American legal system.

Why does this matter for your civil case? Because if we can prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt, we can certainly prove it by a preponderance of the evidence, the lower standard used in civil court. Our background as prosecutors means we build cases that are airtight. We gather evidence the way we would if we had to convince a jury that someone was guilty of a crime. When insurance companies see the strength of our cases, they understand we’re prepared to win at trial if they don’t offer fair compensation.

Our prosecutorial experience also helps us understand what’s happening in the criminal case against the drunk driver. We can anticipate how the prosecution will proceed, what evidence they’ll rely on, and how the criminal case might affect your civil claim. This insight allows us to coordinate strategy in ways that other firms simply cannot.

A Personal Injury Team That Has Recovered Millions for Texans

While our criminal law expertise sets us apart, our personal injury team has the skills and track record to maximize your recovery. We have recovered millions of dollars for Texas families in wrongful death cases, car accidents, truck accidents, and other serious injury claims.

We don’t just file lawsuits and hope for the best. We investigate every potential source of recovery. We work with accident reconstructionists, medical experts, economists, and life care planners to document the full extent of your loss. We calculate not just what your family has lost today, but what you’ll lose over decades without your loved one’s income, guidance, and presence.

Insurance companies know which firms will fight and which will accept lowball offers. They know we have the resources to take cases to trial and the courtroom experience to win. This reputation means we often secure better settlements without ever stepping into a courtroom, because the other side knows what will happen if we do.

A Team of Over 70 Legal Professionals

Varghese Summersett is not a small operation. We have a team of over 70 attorneys and legal professionals across offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake. This means we have the resources to handle complex cases that smaller firms cannot. We can dedicate investigators, paralegals, and attorneys to your case without cutting corners.

Our size also means we can absorb the costs of litigation. Wrongful death cases require expert witnesses, accident reconstruction, medical records analysis, and sometimes years of legal work before resolution. We advance all of these costs and only get paid if we recover compensation for your family.

We Understand What You’re Going Through

Beyond our legal credentials, we approach every wrongful death case with compassion. We know you’re not just a case number. You’ve lost someone you love to a senseless, preventable tragedy. You’re grieving while also trying to figure out how to pay bills, take care of your family, and find some measure of justice.

When you work with Varghese Summersett, you’ll have attorneys who listen to your story, answer your questions, and keep you informed every step of the way. We’ll handle the legal battle so you can focus on healing and taking care of your family.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions About Wrongful Death Claims After Drunk Driving Deaths

How much is a wrongful death case worth in Texas?

Every case is different. The value depends on factors like your loved one’s age and earning capacity, the strength of the evidence, and the available insurance coverage. Cases involving young, high-earning victims with clear liability and significant insurance coverage are worth more than cases with older victims, disputed liability, or minimal coverage. Our attorneys can evaluate your specific situation and give you a realistic assessment of potential recovery.

Can I still sue if the drunk driver was killed in the crash?

Yes. You can file a wrongful death claim against the drunk driver’s estate. Their auto insurance policy will still provide coverage, and any assets in their estate may be available to satisfy a judgment.

What if I was a passenger in the drunk driver’s car?

You still have the right to file a wrongful death claim. Passengers are innocent victims, and Texas law protects their right to seek compensation even when the crash was caused by the driver they were riding with.

Why can’t the prosecutor get me compensation?

The prosecutor represents the State of Texas, not you or your family. Their job is to prove the defendant committed a crime and seek appropriate punishment. While restitution is sometimes ordered in criminal cases, it’s limited and difficult to collect. A wrongful death lawsuit is the legal process designed to compensate victims’ families.

My child lost their father. How do I file a lawsuit for them?

As the child’s parent or legal guardian, you can file a wrongful death lawsuit on their behalf. The court will oversee the case to protect your child’s interests, and any settlement must be approved by a judge. Settlement funds for minors are typically placed in a protected account or structured settlement.

Do I need an attorney to file a wrongful death lawsuit?

While you’re legally allowed to represent yourself, wrongful death cases are complex. They involve investigating the crash, proving the four elements of negligence, identifying all liable parties, calculating damages, negotiating with multiple insurance companies, and potentially going to trial. Insurance companies take unrepresented families less seriously and typically offer lower settlements. An experienced attorney significantly increases both your chances of success and the amount you recover.

How long will the case take?

Most wrongful death cases in Fort Bend County take one to three years from filing to resolution. Cases that settle without trial resolve faster than those that go to court. Complex cases with multiple defendants or disputed liability take longer. We keep our clients informed throughout the process and work efficiently while never sacrificing the quality of your case for speed.

Talk to Our Texas Wrongful Death Attorneys

Get Help From Our Experienced Texas Wrongful Death Attorneys

Losing a loved one to a drunk driver leaves you with grief, anger, and a thousand questions. The criminal justice system may bring some accountability, but the prosecutor works for the state, not for you. If you want an attorney who answers to your family and fights for your interests, you need to file a wrongful death lawsuit.

At Varghese Summersett, we combine what other firms cannot: extensive trial experience in intoxication cases, the prosecutorial background to build cases at the highest burden of proof, and a personal injury team that has recovered millions for Texas families. We have the resources, knowledge, and dedication to hold drunk drivers and those who enabled them fully accountable.

We handle wrongful death cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for your family. We advance all costs of litigation. You owe us nothing if we don’t win.

Your free consultation is a chance to get answers and understand your options. There’s no obligation, no pressure, and no cost. We just want to help you understand what your family can do next.

Call (281) 805-2220 today to speak with a wrongful death attorney who will listen to your story and fight for your family.

Varghese Summersett

Were You Searched Without a Warrant? Here’s What You Need to Know

If police searched your car, your home, or your person without your permission, you’re probably wondering whether what they did was legal. The answer matters because evidence from an illegal search by police cannot be used against you in court. Under the Fourth Amendment and Texas Code of Criminal Procedure Article 38.23 , illegally obtained evidence must be thrown out, which can mean the difference between a conviction and a dismissal.

At Varghese Summersett, our criminal defense attorneys have successfully challenged unlawful searches in courts throughout Fort Worth , Dallas, Houston, Fort Bend, and across Texas. We’ve seen firsthand how police sometimes cut corners, ignore constitutional protections, or pressure people into consenting to searches they had every right to refuse. If you believe your rights were violated, you need to act quickly. Call (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation with a Board Certified criminal defense attorney.

What Makes a Search by Police Illegal

What Makes a Search by Police Illegal?

A search becomes illegal when police violate your Fourth Amendment rights by searching without a valid warrant, without your consent, and without an applicable exception. The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects you from “unreasonable searches and seizures” and requires that warrants be supported by probable cause.

In Texas, these protections go even further. Article I, Section 9 of the Texas Constitution provides similar safeguards, and Texas courts have historically interpreted these protections broadly in favor of defendants. This means evidence that might be admissible in federal court could still be suppressed in a Texas state court.

A search is generally illegal when:

  • Police searched without a warrant and no exception applied
  • The warrant was based on false or misleading information
  • Police exceeded the scope of a valid warrant
  • Your consent was coerced or not truly voluntary
  • Police lacked reasonable suspicion to detain you in the first place

Your Fourth Amendment Rights in Police Encounters

What Are Your Fourth Amendment Rights During a Police Encounter?

Your Fourth Amendment rights protect you from government intrusion into areas where you have a “reasonable expectation of privacy.” This includes your home (which receives the highest protection), your vehicle, your personal belongings, and your body. Understanding these rights can help you recognize when police have crossed the line.

You have the right to refuse a search. If an officer asks, “Do you mind if I look around?” you can say no. Police often ask because they know they lack legal grounds to search without permission. Saying yes waives your constitutional protection. Saying no preserves your rights and any future legal challenges.

You also have the right to remain silent. You must provide identification if asked during a lawful detention in Texas, but you don’t have to answer questions about where you’re going, what you’re doing, or whether you have anything illegal. Politely but firmly stating “I don’t consent to searches” and “I’m exercising my right to remain silent” protects you without escalating the situation.

When Can Police Search Without a Warrant

When Can Police Search Without a Warrant?

While the Fourth Amendment generally requires a warrant, courts have recognized several exceptions. Police and prosecutors will argue these exceptions apply to justify a warrantless search. A skilled defense attorney knows how to challenge these claims.

Consent

If you voluntarily agree to a search, police don’t need a warrant. But consent must be freely given, not the result of coercion, threats, or deception. If officers said something like “It’ll go easier if you cooperate” or implied you had no choice, your consent may not have been voluntary. Texas courts examine the totality of circumstances, including whether you were in custody, whether weapons were displayed, and whether you were told you could refuse.

Search Incident to Arrest

When police lawfully arrest you, they can search your person and the area within your immediate control. However, this exception has limits. In Arizona v. Gant, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that police cannot search a vehicle incident to arrest once the arrestee is secured and cannot access the car. If you were handcuffed in the back of a patrol car when officers searched your vehicle, this exception likely doesn’t apply. For this reason, most cities have a tow policy that allows them search incident to the tow following an arrest.

Plain View

Officers can seize evidence in plain view if they’re lawfully present and the illegal nature of the item is immediately apparent. But they cannot move objects or manipulate items to get a better look. If an officer opened your glove box or lifted a blanket to find contraband, that’s not plain view.

Automobile Exception

Because vehicles are mobile and have a reduced expectation of privacy, police can search a car without a warrant if they have probable cause to believe it contains evidence of a crime. The key word is probable cause, not mere suspicion. The smell of marijuana alone, for example, has been challenged in Texas courts, especially as CBD products have become legal and indistinguishable by smell from illegal marijuana.

Exigent Circumstances

Police can act without a warrant when there’s an emergency, such as someone in danger, a suspect actively fleeing, or evidence being destroyed. But officers cannot create the emergency themselves and then use it to justify a warrantless search. Texas courts scrutinize these claims carefully.

How Evidence Suppression Works in Texas

How Does Suppression of Evidence Work in Texas?

When police conduct an illegal search, the remedy is suppression. This means the evidence cannot be used against you at trial. In Texas, the exclusionary rule is codified in Article 38.23 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, which states that no evidence obtained in violation of the constitution or laws shall be admitted.

Texas’s exclusionary rule is broader than the federal version. While federal courts have created exceptions (like the “good faith” exception for officers who reasonably relied on a defective warrant), Texas courts do not recognize these exceptions. If the search violated your rights, the evidence is out, period.

Your attorney challenges an illegal search by filing a motion to suppress before trial. At a suppression hearing, the prosecution must prove the search was legal. If they can’t, the judge excludes the evidence. Without key evidence, prosecutors often have no choice but to reduce charges or dismiss the case entirely.

This is why hiring the right attorney matters. Varghese Summersett’s defense team includes former prosecutors who know how the other side thinks. We’ve handled hundreds of suppression hearings and understand what it takes to win. Call (817) 203-2220 to discuss your case.

Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Explained

What Is the “Fruit of the Poisonous Tree” Doctrine?

The fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine extends suppression beyond the illegally obtained evidence itself. Any evidence discovered as a result of the illegal search is also inadmissible. For example, if police illegally searched your car, found an address, went to that address, and found drugs, those drugs are “fruit” of the original poisonous search and must be suppressed too.

This doctrine recognizes that allowing police to benefit from unconstitutional conduct would encourage future violations. It’s a powerful tool for defense attorneys, but it requires careful analysis of the chain of events leading to each piece of evidence.

Challenging an Illegal Traffic Stop in Tarrant County

Real Case Example: Challenging an Illegal Traffic Stop in Tarrant County

Our attorneys represented a client in Tarrant County who was charged with felony possession of a controlled substance after a traffic stop. The officer claimed he stopped the vehicle for “failing to signal a lane change.” Our investigation revealed dash cam footage showed no evidence that the client failed to signal the lane change. The entire stop was unsupported by reasonable suspicion.

We filed a motion to suppress, arguing that everything after the illegal stop was fruit of the poisonous tree. The judge agreed. With the drugs suppressed, the prosecution had no case. The charges were dismissed entirely, and our client avoided what could have been years in prison.

Every case is different, and past results don’t guarantee future outcomes. But this example shows why challenging the legality of a search can be the most important part of your defense.

What to Do After an Illegal Search

What Should You Do If Police Conducted an Illegal Search?

If you believe police violated your rights, take these steps to protect yourself and your case:

Don’t resist or argue at the scene. Even if the search is illegal, physically resisting can lead to additional charges. Stay calm, don’t consent, and let your attorney fight the battle in court.

Document everything you remember. Write down what happened as soon as possible. Note the officers’ names and badge numbers, what they said, whether they asked for consent, and how they conducted the search. Details fade quickly, and your notes could be critical.

Don’t discuss your case. Anything you say to friends, family, or on social media can potentially be used against you. The only person you should discuss details with is your attorney.

Contact a criminal defense attorney immediately. There are deadlines for filing motions to suppress evidence. An experienced attorney can review the facts, identify constitutional violations, and build your defense strategy.

What Happens After You Contact Us

What Happens After You Contact Varghese Summersett?

When you call our firm, you’ll speak directly with a member of our criminal defense team, not an answering service. During your free consultation, we’ll listen to what happened, explain your rights, and give you an honest assessment of your case.

If we take your case, we immediately begin investigating. This includes obtaining police reports, dash cam and body cam footage, witness statements, and any other evidence. We analyze every detail for constitutional violations. If we find grounds for suppression, we file the motion and prepare for a hearing.

Throughout the process, we keep you informed. You’ll know what’s happening, what to expect, and what decisions need to be made. Facing criminal charges is stressful enough. We handle the legal complexity so you can focus on your life.

Why Varghese Summersett

Why Choose Varghese Summersett for Your Defense?

Not all criminal defense firms are equipped to handle complex constitutional challenges. At Varghese Summersett, our team includes Board Certified specialists in criminal law, a designation held by less than 10% of Texas attorneys. We have former prosecutors who understand how the state builds cases and where they’re vulnerable.

Our attorneys have tried cases in state and federal courts throughout Texas. We’ve argued suppression motions before judges in Tarrant, Dallas, Denton, Collin, and Harris Counties. We know the local procedures, the prosecutors, and what it takes to win.

With more than 100 years of combined experience and over 1,100 five-star reviews from clients, we’ve built a reputation for aggressive, effective defense. When your freedom is on the line, you deserve attorneys who will fight for every advantage the law provides.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Frequently Asked Questions About Illegal Searches by Police

Can police search my car during a traffic stop?

Police can only search your car during a traffic stop if they have probable cause, you consent, or another exception applies. Simply pulling you over for a traffic violation does not automatically give them the right to search. You can and should politely refuse consent. If they search anyway without legal justification, the evidence may be suppressed.

What if I consented to the search but felt pressured?

Consent must be voluntary to be valid. If officers used threats, intimidation, or implied you had no choice, your consent may not hold up in court. Texas courts look at all the circumstances, including whether you were told you could refuse, whether you were detained, and whether officers displayed weapons or used aggressive tactics.

Can evidence still be used if police made a mistake?

In federal court, the “good faith” exception sometimes allows evidence obtained through honest police mistakes. However, Texas does not recognize this exception under Article 38.23. If the search violated your constitutional rights, the evidence is inadmissible in Texas courts regardless of the officer’s intent.

How long do I have to challenge an illegal search?

Motions to suppress must typically be filed before trial. In Texas, this usually means filing during the pretrial phase. Missing this deadline can waive your right to challenge the evidence, which is why contacting an attorney quickly is so important.

What happens if the evidence is suppressed?

If key evidence is suppressed, the prosecution may not have enough to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt. This often leads to reduced charges, favorable plea agreements, or complete dismissal. Suppression doesn’t guarantee dismissal, but it fundamentally changes the strength of the prosecution’s case.

Talk to Our Criminal Defense Attorney Today

Protect Your Rights. Call a Texas Criminal Defense Attorney Today.

An illegal search can turn your life upside down. But evidence obtained in violation of your constitutional rights doesn’t have to destroy your future. With the right defense, you may be able to have that evidence thrown out and your charges reduced or dismissed.

At Varghese Summersett, we’ve helped hundreds of Texans challenge illegal searches and fight back against criminal charges. Our Board Certified criminal defense attorneys know how to identify police misconduct, build compelling suppression motions, and advocate aggressively for your rights.

Call (817) 203-2220 today for a free, confidential consultation. The sooner you act, the more options you have. Let us review what happened, explain your rights, and show you a path forward.

Varghese Summersett

Texas Auto Insurance Requirements

Texas law requires all drivers to carry minimum liability insurance, but here’s what most people don’t realize until it’s too late: the state minimum of 30/60/25 often leaves accident victims tens of thousands of dollars short of covering their actual losses. If you’ve been seriously injured by an underinsured driver, or you’re wondering whether your own coverage will protect your family, understanding these numbers could be the most important financial decision you make this year.

At Varghese Summersett, our personal injury attorneys have seen countless clients suffer devastating injuries only to discover the at-fault driver carried the bare minimum coverage. We’ve also helped clients navigate the complex process of recovering compensation through their own underinsured motorist policies. This guide explains what Texas requires, why it’s not enough, and how to actually protect yourself.

If you’ve been injured in a car accident and are dealing with insurance issues, call our team at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation.

Minimum Car Insurance Texas

Under Texas Transportation Code § 601.072, every driver must carry liability insurance with at least these minimum limits:

$30,000 for bodily injury per person
$60,000 for total bodily injury per accident (when multiple people are hurt)
$25,000 for property damage per accident

This is commonly written as “30/60/25” coverage. You’ll see it on your insurance declarations page and in policy documents. Texas has required this coverage since 2008, when the minimums increased from the previous 20/40/15 standard.

These amounts represent the maximum your liability insurance will pay if you cause an accident that injures someone else or damages their property. Once you hit that ceiling, you’re personally responsible for any remaining costs.

What Does Liability Coverage Actually Pay For?

Liability coverage protects other people when you’re at fault in an accident. It pays for the other driver’s medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and vehicle repairs. It does not pay for your own injuries or damage to your own car.

Here’s how those limits work in practice. Say you run a red light and hit another vehicle. The other driver breaks her leg and needs surgery. Her medical bills total $45,000, she misses six weeks of work ($8,000 in lost wages), and her car is totaled ($20,000).

Her damages exceed $73,000. Your 30/60/25 policy would pay $30,000 toward her injury claim and $20,000 for her car (assuming that was her actual value). She’s still $23,000 short on her medical bills alone, not counting pain and suffering or lost wages.

That remaining amount? She can sue you personally for it. Your savings, your house, your future wages could all be at risk.

Why Texas Minimum Coverage Is Dangerously Inadequate

The 30/60/25 minimum was set in 2008. It hasn’t changed since, despite medical costs rising dramatically. According to the Health Care Cost Institute, average emergency room visits now cost over $2,000. A single night in the hospital averages more than $3,000. Serious injuries requiring surgery, rehabilitation, or long-term care can easily exceed $100,000.

Our attorneys at Varghese Summersett regularly handle cases where clients face medical bills of $50,000, $100,000, or more. In 2023, we represented a client struck by a distracted driver in Fort Worth whose spinal surgery alone cost $127,000. The at-fault driver carried only minimum coverage. Without our client’s own underinsured motorist policy, she would have recovered less than a quarter of her medical expenses.

Property damage limits are equally outdated. The average new car in Texas costs over $48,000. Even used vehicles commonly sell for $25,000 to $35,000. If you total someone’s car, that $25,000 property damage limit may not cover it.

What Happens If You’re Hit by an Uninsured or Underinsured Driver

Texas has one of the highest rates of uninsured drivers in the country. According to the Insurance Research Council, approximately 14% of Texas motorists drive without any insurance at all. That’s roughly one in seven drivers on the road with you right now.

Even more drivers carry only the state minimum. When these drivers cause serious accidents, their coverage runs out quickly, leaving victims with few options.

This is where uninsured motorist (UM) and underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage becomes essential. These optional coverages protect you and your family when the other driver can’t cover your losses.

Uninsured Motorist Coverage (UM) pays your medical bills, lost wages, and other damages when the at-fault driver has no insurance at all. It also covers hit-and-run accidents where the driver flees.

Underinsured Motorist Coverage (UIM) kicks in when the at-fault driver’s insurance isn’t enough to cover your damages. If your injuries cost $80,000 and the other driver only has $30,000 in coverage, your UIM policy covers the gap.

Texas law requires insurance companies to offer you UM/UIM coverage, but you can reject it in writing. Many Texans decline this coverage to save money on premiums without understanding what they’re giving up.

How UM/UIM Coverage Works in a Real Case

One of our clients was rear-ended at a stoplight on I-35 in Dallas by a driver who was texting. Our client suffered herniated discs requiring two surgeries and months of physical therapy. Her total medical bills exceeded $210,000, and she couldn’t work for eight months.

The at-fault driver carried only $30,000 in liability coverage. His insurance paid that amount quickly, but it barely covered a fraction of her losses.

Fortunately, our client had $100,000 in underinsured motorist coverage on her own policy. After exhausting the at-fault driver’s limits, we filed a UIM claim with her insurance company. Through negotiation, we recovered an additional $95,000 from her own policy.

Without UIM coverage, she would have been left with over $180,000 in unpaid medical bills. The extra premium she paid for UIM coverage, roughly $150 per year, saved her from financial ruin.

What Is an Umbrella Policy and Why Should You Consider One?

An umbrella policy provides an extra layer of liability protection above your auto and homeowner’s insurance limits. It kicks in after your underlying policies max out.

Umbrella policies typically start at $1 million in coverage and can go much higher. The cost is surprisingly affordable. Most people pay between $150 and $300 per year for $1 million in umbrella coverage.

Consider this scenario. You cause an accident that seriously injures a family of four. Their combined medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering total $400,000. Your auto policy with 100/300/50 limits pays $300,000, but you’re still $100,000 short. Without an umbrella policy, that $100,000 comes out of your personal assets.

Umbrella policies also cover you in situations beyond car accidents. They protect against lawsuits from injuries on your property, defamation claims, and other liability exposures. For anyone with assets to protect, including a home, savings, or retirement accounts, umbrella coverage is one of the smartest insurance purchases available.

How Much Auto Insurance Coverage Do You Actually Need?

Insurance agents have a general rule: carry enough liability coverage to protect your net worth. If you have $200,000 in assets, you should have at least $200,000 in liability coverage. But that’s just the starting point.

Most financial advisors recommend at least 100/300/100 coverage for Texas drivers. This means $100,000 per person for bodily injury, $300,000 total per accident, and $100,000 for property damage. Combined with a $1 million umbrella policy, this provides solid protection for most families.

For UM/UIM coverage, match your liability limits. If you carry 100/300/100 liability, carry the same for uninsured and underinsured motorist protection. This ensures you’re protected whether you cause an accident or are the victim of one.

What to Do After a Car Accident in Texas

If you’ve been in an accident, especially one involving serious injuries, the steps you take immediately after can affect your ability to recover compensation.

At the scene: Call 911 and report the accident. Exchange insurance information with all drivers involved. Take photos of vehicle damage, the accident scene, and any visible injuries. Get contact information from witnesses.

Within 24-48 hours: Seek medical attention, even if you feel fine. Many injuries don’t show symptoms right away. Document everything in writing while your memory is fresh.

When dealing with insurance: Report the accident to your own insurance company promptly. Be careful what you say to the other driver’s insurance company. They may try to get you to admit fault or minimize your injuries. You are not required to give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer.

Before accepting any settlement: Talk to a personal injury attorney. Insurance companies often make quick lowball offers before you understand the full extent of your injuries. Once you sign a release, you can’t go back for more money.

What Happens After You Call Varghese Summersett

When you contact our firm after a car accident, here’s what to expect. First, you’ll speak with a member of our personal injury team who will ask about your accident and injuries. This initial call is free and confidential.

If we believe you have a case, we’ll schedule a consultation to review your medical records, insurance policies, and the facts of your accident. We handle personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you.

Our team will deal with the insurance companies so you can focus on recovery. We gather evidence, negotiate with adjusters, and prepare your case for trial if necessary. We’ve recovered millions for injured Texans, and we fight hard to maximize every client’s recovery.

Frequently Asked Questions About Texas Auto Insurance

Can I drive legally in Texas with just liability insurance?

Yes. Texas law only requires liability coverage at the 30/60/25 minimum. However, this protects other people, not you. If you’re injured by an uninsured driver and you don’t have UM coverage, you may have no way to recover your medical expenses.

Does my insurance cover me if I’m driving someone else’s car?

Generally, auto insurance follows the car first and the driver second. The car owner’s insurance is primary. Your insurance acts as secondary coverage if the owner’s policy isn’t enough or doesn’t apply.

What happens if I’m hit by an uninsured driver and I don’t have UM coverage?

You can sue the uninsured driver personally, but collecting is often difficult or impossible. Many uninsured drivers have few assets. Without UM coverage, you may be left paying your own medical bills even though the accident wasn’t your fault.

How long do I have to file an insurance claim after an accident in Texas?

You should report accidents to your insurance company as soon as possible, typically within a few days. For lawsuits against the at-fault driver, Texas has a two-year statute of limitations from the date of the accident. However, waiting can hurt your case as evidence disappears and memories fade.

Will my rates go up if I file a UM/UIM claim?

Texas Insurance Code § 1952.0545 prohibits insurers from raising your rates solely because you filed a UM/UIM claim for an accident that wasn’t your fault. If your rates increase, it should be based on other factors.

Get Help from an Experienced Texas Personal Injury Attorney

Understanding your insurance coverage is one thing. Knowing how to use it when you’re injured is another. Insurance companies, including your own, are businesses focused on minimizing payouts. Having an experienced attorney on your side levels the playing field.

At Varghese Summersett, our personal injury lawyers have decades of combined experience handling auto accident cases across Texas. We’ve recovered compensation for clients in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and throughout the state. We understand the tactics insurance companies use to reduce or deny claims, and we know how to fight back.

If you’ve been injured in a car accident, don’t navigate the insurance process alone. Call us at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ll review your case, explain your options, and help you understand what your claim is really worth. You pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you.

Varghese Summersett

What Is Reasonable Suspicion in Texas?

Reasonable suspicion is the legal standard police must meet before they can pull you over or temporarily detain you. It requires more than a hunch or gut feeling. Officers must point to specific, articulable facts that suggest criminal activity is happening. Without it, the stop is unconstitutional, and any evidence gathered can be thrown out of court.

On December 19, 2025, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reminded law enforcement of this rule in Hernandez v. State . The court threw out a conviction because an officer stopped a driver without reasonable suspicion, despite the stop having been upheld at the trial and intermediate court level.

At Varghese Summersett, our criminal defense attorneys have built careers challenging unlawful stops in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and courts across Texas. If you were stopped, searched, or arrested after a traffic stop you believe was illegal, call us at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation.

The Legal Definition of Reasonable Suspicion

The Legal Definition of Reasonable Suspicion

The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and Article I, Section 9 of the Texas Constitution protect you from unreasonable searches and seizures. A traffic stop counts as a “seizure” under the law. That means police need a valid legal reason to pull you over.

Reasonable suspicion sits between a mere hunch and probable cause (the higher standard needed for an arrest). To meet this standard, an officer must identify specific facts that, combined with rational inferences from their training and experience, suggest criminal activity is occurring or about to occur.

The U.S. Supreme Court established this standard in Terry v. Ohio (1968), and Texas courts have applied it consistently ever since. The key word is “specific.” Officers cannot rely on vague feelings or generalized suspicions. They must be able to explain exactly what facts made them believe a crime was happening.

What Counts as Reasonable Suspicion for a Traffic Stop

Texas courts have recognized several situations where reasonable suspicion exists:

  • Traffic violations: Speeding, running a red light, failing to signal, expired registration, or broken taillights give officers clear grounds to stop you.
  • Erratic driving: Weaving between lanes, driving significantly below the speed limit on a highway, or other behavior consistent with impairment can justify a stop.
  • Reliable witness reports: A detailed, corroborated tip describing specific criminal activity and a particular vehicle may support reasonable suspicion.
  • Plain view observations: If an officer sees contraband or evidence of a crime through your window while lawfully positioned, this can justify further action.
  • Matching a suspect description: If you closely match a detailed description from a recent crime report in the immediate area, officers may have grounds to stop you briefly.

What Does NOT Count as Reasonable Suspicion

Just as important is knowing what police cannot use to justify a stop:

  • Driving in a “high crime” area: Your presence in a particular neighborhood, standing alone, is not reasonable suspicion.
  • Looking nervous: Many innocent people feel anxious around police. Nervousness alone cannot justify a stop.
  • Driving slowly: Unless you’re impeding traffic or driving dangerously below the limit, slow driving is legal.
  • Vague anonymous tips: A caller saying someone looks “suspicious” without describing criminal behavior is not enough.
  • Race, ethnicity, or appearance: Stops based on how you look rather than what you’re doing are unconstitutional.
  • Time of day: Driving late at night is not a crime and cannot be the sole basis for a stop.

In 2023, our attorneys represented a client in Tarrant County who was pulled over because he was driving a “nice car” through a certain neighborhood at night. The officer admitted he had no other reason for the stop. We filed a motion to suppress, the court agreed the stop was unlawful, and the felony drug charges were dismissed.

The Hernandez V. State ruling_ A Landmark Victory for Drivers

The Hernandez v. State Ruling: A Landmark Victory for Drivers

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals just handed down a decision that reinforces reasonable suspicion protections for every Texas driver. In Hernandez v. State (PD-0176-25), decided December 19, 2025, the court reversed a conviction because the initial traffic stop lacked reasonable suspicion.

What Happened in This Case

It started with an anonymous 911 call. A woman reported seeing a “suspicious” four-door Chevrolet Silverado driving slowly through rural Willacy County. She didn’t report any crime. She didn’t describe dangerous driving. Just a truck moving slowly.

Thirty minutes later, Officer Garcia arrived. He didn’t find a Chevrolet Silverado. Instead, he spotted a completely different pickup truck on a dirt road. Despite the vehicle not matching the caller’s description and the driver committing no traffic violation, Officer Garcia activated his emergency lights.

Mr. Hernandez continued at a slow pace before stopping to open a gate on the property. A physical altercation followed, and Hernandez was arrested for evading arrest or detention with a motor vehicle under Texas Penal Code § 38.04.

The 197th District Court of Willacy County convicted him. The Thirteenth Court of Appeals affirmed. But the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals saw it differently.

The Court’s Reasoning

Writing for the court, Judge Lee Finley held that no rational juror could conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that Officer Garcia had reasonable suspicion. The court’s analysis was direct:

The vehicle didn’t match the 911 caller’s description. The driver wasn’t breaking any traffic laws. Driving slowly on a rural dirt road isn’t criminal. Officer Garcia had no specific, articulable facts linking Mr. Hernandez to any crime.

Because the initial stop was unlawful, the evading arrest charge collapsed. You cannot evade a “lawful detention” when there was no lawful basis for the detention in the first place. The court rendered a judgment of acquittal, meaning the case is over and Mr. Hernandez is free.

How Anonymous Tips Affect Reasonable Suspicion

How Anonymous Tips Affect Reasonable Suspicion

Anonymous 911 calls present a unique challenge for courts. The caller’s credibility cannot be verified, so Texas law treats these tips with healthy skepticism.

An anonymous tip alone is usually not enough to justify a stop. Under Texas law, officers must independently corroborate specific details before acting. The tip must also describe actual criminal behavior, not just something that seems “off” to the caller.

The U.S. Supreme Court addressed this in Navarette v. California (2014). The Court held that a 911 call can support reasonable suspicion if it includes enough specific details that officers can verify. But even a detailed tip must describe criminal conduct. Reporting that someone is “driving slowly” or “looks suspicious” doesn’t cut it.

In Hernandez, the anonymous caller only said a vehicle looked suspicious. That’s not a crime. And Officer Garcia compounded the problem by stopping a vehicle that didn’t even match the description. The stop was doomed from the start.

If you were stopped based on an anonymous tip, our attorneys will examine whether police had enough verified information to justify the stop. In many cases, they don’t.

Why Reasonable Suspicion Matters For Your Case

Why Reasonable Suspicion Matters for Your Case

A traffic stop might seem minor, but it’s often the first domino in a chain that leads to serious criminal charges. Once an officer pulls you over, they can:

  • Ask questions that lead to incriminating statements
  • Claim to smell marijuana or alcohol, justifying a search
  • Run your information and discover unrelated warrants
  • Request field sobriety tests that lead to DWI arrests
  • Search your vehicle if they develop probable cause

Every one of these outcomes depends on the initial stop being lawful. If the stop lacked reasonable suspicion, everything that followed can potentially be challenged under the “fruit of the poisonous tree” doctrine. This legal principle holds that evidence obtained through unconstitutional means cannot be used against you.

Challenging an Unlawful Stop_ Defenses that Work

Challenging an Unlawful Stop: Defenses That Work

When police violate your constitutional rights, Texas law gives you tools to fight back. Here’s how our attorneys challenge unlawful stops:

Motion to Suppress Evidence

This is the most powerful tool in cases involving questionable stops. If the court finds the stop was unconstitutional, any evidence obtained as a result (drugs, weapons, breath test results, statements) gets excluded from trial. Without evidence, prosecutors often have no choice but to dismiss or significantly reduce charges.

Challenging Officer Testimony

Officers must articulate specific facts justifying the stop. We obtain dashcam footage, bodycam recordings, and police reports, then scrutinize them for inconsistencies. If an officer’s story doesn’t add up or their stated reasons don’t match the video evidence, the stop may be deemed unlawful.

Attacking Anonymous Tip Reliability

As Hernandez demonstrates, anonymous tips require corroboration. We examine 911 recordings and compare them to the officer’s observations. If police acted on a vague tip without verification, we challenge the stop’s validity.

Proving the Vehicle Didn’t Match

In Hernandez, the officer stopped a truck that didn’t match the caller’s description at all. We look for similar discrepancies in every case. If officers stopped the wrong vehicle or couldn’t have reasonably believed your car matched a reported description, the stop fails.

Demonstrating Legal Activity

Driving slowly, being out late, looking away from an officer, or being in a certain neighborhood are not crimes. We hold officers to the constitutional standard they must meet, forcing them to identify actual criminal indicators rather than hunches.

Evading Arrest Charges_ Why the Stop Matters

Evading Arrest Charges: Why the Stop Matters

Mr. Hernandez was charged under Texas Penal Code § 38.04, which makes it a crime to intentionally flee from someone you know is a peace officer attempting a lawful detention or arrest.

The statute requires the underlying detention or arrest to be “lawful.” This is the element that destroyed the prosecution’s case in Hernandez. If police had no right to stop you in the first place, you cannot be convicted of evading that stop.

Evading arrest with a motor vehicle is typically a state jail felony, carrying 180 days to two years in a state jail facility. If someone suffers serious bodily injury during the pursuit, the charge elevates to a third-degree felony with two to ten years in prison.

We’ve successfully defended evading cases by attacking the lawfulness of the stop. In one Fort Worth case, our client faced felony evading charges after a pursuit through multiple neighborhoods. By demonstrating that the officer who initiated the stop had no reasonable suspicion, we got the felony charge dismissed.

What to do if You're Pulled Over

What to Do If You’re Pulled Over

Knowing your rights during a traffic stop can protect you from unlawful searches and questionable charges.

Stay calm and keep your hands visible. Place your hands on the steering wheel where the officer can see them. This reduces tension and prevents misunderstandings.

Provide required documents. You must give the officer your driver’s license, registration, and proof of insurance. Refusing these can lead to additional charges.

Exercise your right to remain silent. Beyond identifying yourself, you don’t have to answer questions about where you’re going, where you’ve been, or what you’ve been doing. A polite “I prefer not to answer questions” is sufficient.

Refuse consent to search. If an officer asks to search your vehicle, you can say no. Without your consent, they need probable cause or a warrant. Your refusal cannot be used against you in court.

Don’t physically resist. Even if the stop is unlawful, resisting creates additional charges and risks your safety. Assert your rights verbally, comply with the officer’s instructions, and challenge the stop later with your attorney.

Document everything afterward. Write down the officer’s name and badge number, the time and location, what was said, and the names of any witnesses. This information helps your attorney challenge the stop.

What Happens After You Call Varghese Summersett

What Happens After You Call Varghese Summersett

Facing criminal charges after a traffic stop is stressful. Here’s what you can expect when you reach out to our firm:

Free initial consultation. We’ll listen to what happened, review the circumstances of your stop and arrest, and give you an honest assessment of your options.

Comprehensive investigation. Our team obtains all available evidence: police reports, dashcam and bodycam footage, 911 recordings, dispatch logs, and witness statements. We look for every weakness in the prosecution’s case.

Strategic motion practice. If your rights were violated, we file motions to suppress evidence. We’ve secured dismissals and reductions in countless cases after successful suppression hearings.

Trial-ready defense. While many cases resolve before trial, we prepare every case as if it’s going before a jury. Prosecutors know we’re willing to fight, which strengthens our negotiating position.

Clear, consistent communication. You’ll always know where your case stands. We return calls promptly and explain each step without legal jargon.

Frequently Asked Questions About Reasonable Suspicion

Frequently Asked Questions About Reasonable Suspicion

Can police pull me over just for being in a “bad” neighborhood?

No. Your presence in a particular area, by itself, is not reasonable suspicion. Officers must observe specific facts suggesting criminal activity. Texas courts have repeatedly rejected stops based solely on location.

What if an anonymous caller reported my vehicle?

An anonymous tip alone is usually not enough. Officers must corroborate specific details from the tip before stopping you. The tip must also describe actual criminal behavior, not just “suspicious” activity. As Hernandez shows, vague tips about slow driving don’t justify stops.

Can an officer search my car after pulling me over?

Only under certain conditions. They can search if you consent, if they have probable cause to believe there’s contraband, if you’re arrested and the search is incident to that arrest, or if they have a warrant. You have the right to refuse consent, and you should.

What happens if the stop was unlawful but I’m already charged?

Contact an attorney immediately. Evidence from an unlawful stop can often be suppressed through a motion hearing. If key evidence is thrown out, prosecutors frequently dismiss or reduce charges. Don’t plead guilty without exploring this option.

Does the Hernandez ruling apply throughout Texas?

Yes. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals is the highest criminal court in the state. Its decisions are binding on every Texas court. This ruling strengthens reasonable suspicion protections statewide.

How long do I have to challenge an unlawful stop?

Timing depends on your case’s procedural posture. Motions to suppress must typically be filed before trial. If you’ve already been convicted, you may have appeal options, but deadlines are strict. Contact an attorney as soon as possible to preserve your rights.

Protect Your Rights with an Experienced Texas Criminal Defense Attorney

Protect Your Rights with an Experienced Texas Criminal Defense Attorney

The Hernandez v. State ruling is a powerful reminder that police must follow the Constitution. But court decisions only protect you if you have an attorney who knows how to use them.

At Varghese Summersett, our defense team includes former prosecutors who understand how the other side thinks, board-certified criminal law specialists, and attorneys who have handled thousands of cases in Texas courts. We know how to spot unlawful stops, build winning suppression motions, and hold the government to its burden of proof.

With team members across offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake, we have the resources to thoroughly investigate your case and fight for the best possible outcome. Our attorneys have earned recognition from Super Lawyers, Texas Monthly, and the National Trial Lawyers, and our firm has been named to the Inc. 5000 list of fastest-growing companies.

If you’ve been arrested after a traffic stop you believe was unlawful, time matters. Evidence must be preserved, and legal deadlines are unforgiving. Call (817) 203-2220 today for a free, confidential consultation. Let us review your case and explain your options. You have rights. We’re here to protect them.

Tough cases call for the toughest lawyers.

Varghese Summersett

What Is a Gap in Treatment After a Car Accident?

A gap in treatment is any delay between your accident and your first doctor visit, or a pause in your ongoing medical care. Insurance companies use these gaps to argue you weren’t really hurt, and it’s one of the fastest ways to destroy a legitimate personal injury claim.

If you’ve been in a car accident in Texas and haven’t seen a doctor yet, or you stopped going to appointments, your claim may already be losing value by the day. The good news: an experienced personal injury attorney can often help explain or close that gap, but only if you act quickly.

If you’re dealing with a gap in treatment and worried about your claim, call Varghese Summersett at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ve helped thousands of Texans recover compensation even when insurance companies tried to use gaps against them.

Why “I Feel Fine” Is the Most Dangerous Thing You Can Say

You walked away from the crash. You’re sore, maybe a little shaken, but nothing feels broken. You figure you’ll see how you feel in a few days.

This is exactly what insurance companies are counting on.

Here’s what’s actually happening in your body: Immediately after a collision, your system floods with adrenaline and endorphins. This is your “fight or flight” response, and it effectively numbs your pain sensors. You might have a herniated disc, torn ligaments, or even internal bleeding, but your brain won’t register it as pain for 24 to 72 hours.

Soft tissue injuries are particularly deceptive. Whiplash, muscle strains, and ligament tears involve microscopic damage that doesn’t show up on X-rays. As inflammation builds over three to five days, the pain often gets worse, not better. By the time you realize something is seriously wrong, you’ve already created a gap that the insurance adjuster will use against you.

In one recent case, our attorneys represented a client who felt “just stiff” after a rear-end collision on I-30 in Fort Worth. She waited six days to see a doctor. By then, her neck pain had become severe. The insurance company’s first offer was 60% lower than what her injuries warranted, and their adjuster argued repeatedly that she must not have been hurt badly since she didn’t seek immediate care. Our team had to fight significantly harder to recover fair compensation for her, documenting the medical reasons for delayed symptom onset and bringing in expert testimony about soft tissue injury patterns.

The lesson: what feels minor today can become a major problem, both physically and legally.

The Timeline: When Insurance Companies Start Cutting Your Claim Value

There’s no Texas statute that says “your claim loses 40% after two weeks.” But after handling thousands of personal injury cases across Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and throughout Texas, our attorneys have seen clear patterns in how adjusters evaluate gaps.

0 to 72 Hours: The Golden Window

This is considered “immediate” treatment. When you see a doctor within three days of an accident, you create a solid, documented link between the crash and your injuries. Insurance companies have a much harder time disputing causation. Your claim retains its full value.

4 to 7 Days: The Suspicious Zone

Adjusters start asking questions. They’ll check whether you went to work during this time. Did you go to the gym? Post on social media about weekend activities? Even if your delayed treatment was reasonable, expect the insurance company to offer 10 to 20% less than your claim is worth. They’ll argue that if you were really hurt, you would have gone sooner.

8 to 14 Days: The Danger Zone

This is where claims start suffering serious damage. Offers typically drop by 40 to 50%. Adjusters will aggressively argue “intervening causes,” meaning they’ll suggest something else caused your injury during that gap period. Did you lift something heavy? Sleep wrong? Fall? They’ll look for any alternative explanation.

30+ Days: The Deal Breaker

At this point, most insurance adjusters will either deny the injury claim entirely or offer what’s called “nuisance value,” sometimes as little as $500 just to make you go away. They’ll assume, at least publicly, that your injuries are unrelated to the crash. Even legitimate, serious injuries become nearly impossible to recover compensation for once you’ve waited this long without documentation.

How Insurance Adjusters Weaponize Your Gap in Treatment

Insurance companies train their adjusters to use gaps strategically. Understanding their playbook helps you see why immediate treatment matters so much.

The “Rational Person” Argument

This is their go-to. The adjuster will argue: “A rational person who is genuinely injured goes to the doctor. You didn’t see a doctor for two weeks. Therefore, you were not injured, or at least not seriously.”

It sounds logical on the surface. Juries sometimes buy it. The problem is that it ignores basic medical reality about delayed symptoms, adrenaline response, and how soft tissue injuries actually work.

The Causation Break

This is the most damaging argument, and the hardest to overcome. To win a personal injury claim in Texas, you must prove that the accident caused your injury. A gap gives the insurance company room to suggest something else did.

Here’s how it plays out: You wait 10 days to see a doctor for back pain. The adjuster responds, “How do we know you didn’t hurt your back lifting groceries on day seven? Or at the gym on day five? Since there’s no medical record from day one, you cannot prove this car accident caused your back pain.”

Without that initial documentation tying your symptoms to the crash, you’re fighting an uphill battle.

Failure to Mitigate Damages

Under Texas law, injured people have a duty to “mitigate” their damages. This means you must take reasonable steps to get better and prevent your injuries from worsening.

If you delay treatment and your condition deteriorates, the insurance company can refuse to pay for that worsening. Their argument: you failed to take care of yourself, so they shouldn’t have to pay for the consequences.

This is particularly brutal with soft tissue injuries. Untreated whiplash can develop into chronic pain. A disc injury that might have healed with early physical therapy can become a surgical case. The insurer will pay for what they claim would have been the outcome with proper treatment, not what actually happened.

What Happens to Your Body After an Accident That You Can’t Feel Yet

Understanding the medical reality helps explain why gaps happen, and why they’re so unfair.

Adrenaline masks your pain. Your body’s stress response suppresses pain signals for hours or even days after trauma. You genuinely feel okay at the scene. That doesn’t mean you are okay.

Inflammation takes time to build. Swelling around injured tissue typically peaks at 48 to 72 hours, not immediately. This is why many accident victims feel worse on day three than they did at the scene.

Internal injuries are silent. Organ damage and internal bleeding don’t always present with dramatic symptoms. Some people have walked around for days with life-threatening internal injuries.

Concussions hide. Traumatic brain injuries often don’t show obvious signs right away. Confusion, headaches, memory problems, and cognitive issues can emerge gradually over days or weeks.

Disc injuries progress. A herniation that feels like mild stiffness today can worsen as it impinges on nerves, eventually causing severe pain, numbness, or weakness in your extremities.

The medical community understands all of this. Insurance adjusters understand it too. They just don’t care, because their job is to pay you as little as possible.

How a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Can Help Close the Gap

Even if you’ve already created a gap, an experienced attorney can sometimes explain it, document it, or minimize its impact. But timing matters.

Controlling the Narrative

Maybe you waited because you don’t have health insurance. Maybe you were afraid of the cost. Maybe you’re a single parent who couldn’t take time off work. Maybe you genuinely thought you were fine until symptoms worsened.

These are valid reasons. But if you don’t document them properly, the insurance company will spin your gap as evidence of fraud or exaggeration. An attorney can help establish a record of why you delayed, so it doesn’t look like you’re making up injuries after the fact.

Letters of Protection

Many people avoid the doctor after an accident because they’re worried about cost. They don’t have health insurance, or they’re afraid of copays and deductibles piling up.

A personal injury attorney can issue what’s called a Letter of Protection (LOP). This is a document that tells the medical provider: treat this patient now, and you’ll be paid out of the eventual settlement. It allows you to get the care you need immediately without paying out of pocket, closing your gap right away.

At Varghese Summersett, we work with a network of medical providers throughout Texas who accept LOPs, ensuring our clients can access treatment regardless of their insurance situation.

Preventing Recorded Statement Mistakes

One of the first things an insurance adjuster will do is ask for a recorded statement. They’ll ask friendly-sounding questions designed to get you to minimize your injuries.

“But you didn’t go to the hospital, so you must have felt okay at the scene, right?”

“You went to work the next day, so the pain couldn’t have been that bad?”

Anything you say can and will be used to reduce your claim. An attorney can handle communications with the insurance company, preventing you from accidentally undermining your own case.

Building the Medical Evidence

Our attorneys work closely with medical professionals to document the connection between your accident and your injuries, even when there’s been a gap. This might include expert testimony explaining delayed symptom onset in soft tissue injuries, medical literature supporting the timeline of your specific injury type, documentation of your symptoms and their progression, and independent medical examinations that establish causation.

This doesn’t guarantee we can overcome a significant gap, but it gives you the best possible chance.

What to Do Right Now If You’ve Been in an Accident

Whether your accident happened today or two weeks ago, here’s what you should do.

If you’re within 72 hours of your accident: Go to urgent care or the emergency room today. Tell the doctor clearly: “I was in a car accident on [date] at [time], and I am experiencing [symptoms].” Be specific and thorough. Mention everything, even symptoms that seem minor. This creates the medical record that protects your claim.

If you’re within one to two weeks: See a doctor immediately. The longer you wait, the more value your claim loses. Even a late record is better than no record.

If it’s been more than two weeks: You still have options, but you need legal help now. Call an attorney before seeing the doctor so they can help you document the gap appropriately.

Regardless of timing: Do not give a recorded statement to the insurance company without talking to an attorney first. Follow through on every medical referral. If the doctor recommends imaging, physical therapy, or specialist evaluation, do it. Don’t skip appointments. Missed visits show up in medical records, and adjusters will find them. Document your symptoms daily. Keep notes on your pain levels, limitations, and how your injuries affect your daily life.

What Happens After You Call Varghese Summersett

We understand that dealing with injuries, medical bills, and insurance companies is overwhelming. Here’s what to expect when you reach out to our team.

During your free consultation, we’ll review the details of your accident, your injuries, and any treatment you’ve received (or haven’t received). We’ll give you an honest assessment of your case, including how any gap in treatment might affect it.

If we take your case, we handle everything: communicating with insurance companies, connecting you with medical providers who accept Letters of Protection, gathering evidence, and fighting for the compensation you deserve.

Our personal injury team has recovered millions of dollars for Texas accident victims. We have offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake, and we handle cases throughout the state.

Frequently Asked Questions About Gaps in Treatment

How long is too long to wait to see a doctor after a car accident?

Ideally, you should seek medical attention within 72 hours. After one week, your claim starts losing value. After two weeks, you’ll face significant challenges. After 30 days, most insurers will deny or severely devalue your claim. However, even with a gap, an attorney may be able to help. Call us for a free consultation to discuss your specific situation.

What if I couldn’t afford to see a doctor after my accident?

This is common, and it’s a valid reason for delay. A personal injury attorney can issue a Letter of Protection that allows you to receive treatment now and pay later out of your settlement. Don’t let cost keep you from getting the care and documentation you need.

Can I still file a claim if I have a gap in treatment?

Yes, but your claim will be harder to prove and likely worth less than it would have been with immediate treatment. An experienced attorney can help document the reasons for your gap and build the strongest possible case given the circumstances.

What counts as a “gap” in treatment?

Both an initial delay (time between the accident and your first doctor visit) and treatment gaps (stopping physical therapy or doctor visits for weeks, then resuming) can hurt your claim. Consistency matters throughout your recovery.

What should I tell the doctor when I go?

Be specific: “I was in a car accident on [date] at [approximate time] and I am experiencing [list all symptoms].” Mention everything, even things that seem minor. This creates the medical record linking your symptoms to the accident.

Protect Your Claim. Talk to a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Today.

Insurance companies have teams of adjusters trained to find reasons to pay you less. A gap in treatment hands them exactly what they need.

At Varghese Summersett, we’ve spent years fighting insurance companies on behalf of injured Texans. We know their tactics, and we know how to counter them. Our firm has more than 70 team members across four Texas offices, and our personal injury attorneys have recovered millions for clients, including many who came to us worried that a gap in treatment had ruined their case.

If you’ve been injured in an accident, whether it happened yesterday or weeks ago, call us at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ll give you an honest assessment of your case and explain your options.

Don’t let a gap in treatment cost you the compensation you deserve. Call Varghese Summersett today.

Varghese Summersett

What Is a Gap in Treatment After a Car Accident?

A gap in treatment is any delay between your accident and your first doctor visit, or a pause in your ongoing medical care. Insurance companies use these gaps to argue you weren’t really hurt, and it’s one of the fastest ways to destroy a legitimate personal injury claim.

If you’ve been in a car accident in Texas and haven’t seen a doctor yet, or you stopped going to appointments, your claim may already be losing value by the day. The good news: an experienced personal injury attorney can often help explain or close that gap, but only if you act quickly.

If you’re dealing with a gap in treatment and worried about your claim, call Varghese Summersett at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ve helped thousands of Texans recover compensation even when insurance companies tried to use gaps against them.

Why “I Feel Fine” Is the Most Dangerous Thing You Can Say

You walked away from the crash. You’re sore, maybe a little shaken, but nothing feels broken. You figure you’ll see how you feel in a few days.

This is exactly what insurance companies are counting on.

Here’s what’s actually happening in your body: Immediately after a collision, your system floods with adrenaline and endorphins. This is your “fight or flight” response, and it effectively numbs your pain sensors. You might have a herniated disc, torn ligaments, or even internal bleeding, but your brain won’t register it as pain for 24 to 72 hours.

Soft tissue injuries are particularly deceptive. Whiplash, muscle strains, and ligament tears involve microscopic damage that doesn’t show up on X-rays. As inflammation builds over three to five days, the pain often gets worse, not better. By the time you realize something is seriously wrong, you’ve already created a gap that the insurance adjuster will use against you.

In one recent case, our attorneys represented a client who felt “just stiff” after a rear-end collision on I-30 in Fort Worth. She waited six days to see a doctor. By then, her neck pain had become severe. The insurance company’s first offer was 60% lower than what her injuries warranted, and their adjuster argued repeatedly that she must not have been hurt badly since she didn’t seek immediate care. Our team had to fight significantly harder to recover fair compensation for her, documenting the medical reasons for delayed symptom onset and bringing in expert testimony about soft tissue injury patterns.

The lesson: what feels minor today can become a major problem, both physically and legally.

The Timeline: When Insurance Companies Start Cutting Your Claim Value

There’s no Texas statute that says “your claim loses 40% after two weeks.” But after handling thousands of personal injury cases across Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and throughout Texas, our attorneys have seen clear patterns in how adjusters evaluate gaps.

0 to 72 Hours: The Golden Window

This is considered “immediate” treatment. When you see a doctor within three days of an accident, you create a solid, documented link between the crash and your injuries. Insurance companies have a much harder time disputing causation. Your claim retains its full value.

4 to 7 Days: The Suspicious Zone

Adjusters start asking questions. They’ll check whether you went to work during this time. Did you go to the gym? Post on social media about weekend activities? Even if your delayed treatment was reasonable, expect the insurance company to offer 10 to 20% less than your claim is worth. They’ll argue that if you were really hurt, you would have gone sooner.

8 to 14 Days: The Danger Zone

This is where claims start suffering serious damage. Offers typically drop by 40 to 50%. Adjusters will aggressively argue “intervening causes,” meaning they’ll suggest something else caused your injury during that gap period. Did you lift something heavy? Sleep wrong? Fall? They’ll look for any alternative explanation.

30+ Days: The Deal Breaker

At this point, most insurance adjusters will either deny the injury claim entirely or offer what’s called “nuisance value,” sometimes as little as $500 just to make you go away. They’ll assume, at least publicly, that your injuries are unrelated to the crash. Even legitimate, serious injuries become nearly impossible to recover compensation for once you’ve waited this long without documentation.

How Insurance Adjusters Weaponize Your Gap in Treatment

Insurance companies train their adjusters to use gaps strategically. Understanding their playbook helps you see why immediate treatment matters so much.

The “Rational Person” Argument

This is their go-to. The adjuster will argue: “A rational person who is genuinely injured goes to the doctor. You didn’t see a doctor for two weeks. Therefore, you were not injured, or at least not seriously.”

It sounds logical on the surface. Juries sometimes buy it. The problem is that it ignores basic medical reality about delayed symptoms, adrenaline response, and how soft tissue injuries actually work.

The Causation Break

This is the most damaging argument, and the hardest to overcome. To win a personal injury claim in Texas, you must prove that the accident caused your injury. A gap gives the insurance company room to suggest something else did.

Here’s how it plays out: You wait 10 days to see a doctor for back pain. The adjuster responds, “How do we know you didn’t hurt your back lifting groceries on day seven? Or at the gym on day five? Since there’s no medical record from day one, you cannot prove this car accident caused your back pain.”

Without that initial documentation tying your symptoms to the crash, you’re fighting an uphill battle.

Failure to Mitigate Damages

Under Texas law, injured people have a duty to “mitigate” their damages. This means you must take reasonable steps to get better and prevent your injuries from worsening.

If you delay treatment and your condition deteriorates, the insurance company can refuse to pay for that worsening. Their argument: you failed to take care of yourself, so they shouldn’t have to pay for the consequences.

This is particularly brutal with soft tissue injuries. Untreated whiplash can develop into chronic pain. A disc injury that might have healed with early physical therapy can become a surgical case. The insurer will pay for what they claim would have been the outcome with proper treatment, not what actually happened.

What Happens to Your Body After an Accident That You Can’t Feel Yet

Understanding the medical reality helps explain why gaps happen, and why they’re so unfair.

Adrenaline masks your pain. Your body’s stress response suppresses pain signals for hours or even days after trauma. You genuinely feel okay at the scene. That doesn’t mean you are okay.

Inflammation takes time to build. Swelling around injured tissue typically peaks at 48 to 72 hours, not immediately. This is why many accident victims feel worse on day three than they did at the scene.

Internal injuries are silent. Organ damage and internal bleeding don’t always present with dramatic symptoms. Some people have walked around for days with life-threatening internal injuries.

Concussions hide. Traumatic brain injuries often don’t show obvious signs right away. Confusion, headaches, memory problems, and cognitive issues can emerge gradually over days or weeks.

Disc injuries progress. A herniation that feels like mild stiffness today can worsen as it impinges on nerves, eventually causing severe pain, numbness, or weakness in your extremities.

The medical community understands all of this. Insurance adjusters understand it too. They just don’t care, because their job is to pay you as little as possible.
get the compensation you deserve with our personal injury lawyers.

How a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Can Help Close the Gap

Even if you’ve already created a gap, an experienced attorney can sometimes explain it, document it, or minimize its impact. But timing matters.

Controlling the Narrative

Maybe you waited because you don’t have health insurance. Maybe you were afraid of the cost. Maybe you’re a single parent who couldn’t take time off work. Maybe you genuinely thought you were fine until symptoms worsened.

These are valid reasons. But if you don’t document them properly, the insurance company will spin your gap as evidence of fraud or exaggeration. An attorney can help establish a record of why you delayed, so it doesn’t look like you’re making up injuries after the fact.

Letters of Protection

Many people avoid the doctor after an accident because they’re worried about cost. They don’t have health insurance, or they’re afraid of copays and deductibles piling up.

A personal injury attorney can issue what’s called a Letter of Protection (LOP). This is a document that tells the medical provider: treat this patient now, and you’ll be paid out of the eventual settlement. It allows you to get the care you need immediately without paying out of pocket, closing your gap right away.

At Varghese Summersett, we work with a network of medical providers throughout Texas who accept LOPs, ensuring our clients can access treatment regardless of their insurance situation.

Preventing Recorded Statement Mistakes

One of the first things an insurance adjuster will do is ask for a recorded statement. They’ll ask friendly-sounding questions designed to get you to minimize your injuries.

“But you didn’t go to the hospital, so you must have felt okay at the scene, right?”

“You went to work the next day, so the pain couldn’t have been that bad?”

Anything you say can and will be used to reduce your claim. An attorney can handle communications with the insurance company, preventing you from accidentally undermining your own case.

Building the Medical Evidence

Our attorneys work closely with medical professionals to document the connection between your accident and your injuries, even when there’s been a gap. This might include expert testimony explaining delayed symptom onset in soft tissue injuries, medical literature supporting the timeline of your specific injury type, documentation of your symptoms and their progression, and independent medical examinations that establish causation.

This doesn’t guarantee we can overcome a significant gap, but it gives you the best possible chance.

What to Do Right Now If You’ve Been in an Accident

Whether your accident happened today or two weeks ago, here’s what you should do.

If you’re within 72 hours of your accident: Go to urgent care or the emergency room today. Tell the doctor clearly: “I was in a car accident on [date] at [time], and I am experiencing [symptoms].” Be specific and thorough. Mention everything, even symptoms that seem minor. This creates the medical record that protects your claim.

If you’re within one to two weeks: See a doctor immediately. The longer you wait, the more value your claim loses. Even a late record is better than no record.

If it’s been more than two weeks: You still have options, but you need legal help now. Call an attorney before seeing the doctor so they can help you document the gap appropriately.

Regardless of timing: Do not give a recorded statement to the insurance company without talking to an attorney first. Follow through on every medical referral. If the doctor recommends imaging, physical therapy, or specialist evaluation, do it. Don’t skip appointments. Missed visits show up in medical records, and adjusters will find them. Document your symptoms daily. Keep notes on your pain levels, limitations, and how your injuries affect your daily life.

CTA: Injured? We can help.

What Happens After You Call Varghese Summersett

We understand that dealing with injuries, medical bills, and insurance companies is overwhelming. Here’s what to expect when you reach out to our team.

During your free consultation, we’ll review the details of your accident, your injuries, and any treatment you’ve received (or haven’t received). We’ll give you an honest assessment of your case, including how any gap in treatment might affect it.

If we take your case, we handle everything: communicating with insurance companies, connecting you with medical providers who accept Letters of Protection, gathering evidence, and fighting for the compensation you deserve.

Our personal injury team has recovered millions of dollars for Texas accident victims. We have offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake, and we handle cases throughout the state.

Frequently Asked Question

Frequently Asked Questions About Gaps in Treatment

How long is too long to wait to see a doctor after a car accident?

Ideally, you should seek medical attention within 72 hours. After one week, your claim starts losing value. After two weeks, you’ll face significant challenges. After 30 days, most insurers will deny or severely devalue your claim. However, even with a gap, an attorney may be able to help. Call us for a free consultation to discuss your specific situation.

What if I couldn’t afford to see a doctor after my accident?

This is common, and it’s a valid reason for delay. A personal injury attorney can issue a Letter of Protection that allows you to receive treatment now and pay later out of your settlement. Don’t let cost keep you from getting the care and documentation you need.

Can I still file a claim if I have a gap in treatment?

Yes, but your claim will be harder to prove and likely worth less than it would have been with immediate treatment. An experienced attorney can help document the reasons for your gap and build the strongest possible case given the circumstances.

What counts as a “gap” in treatment?

Both an initial delay (time between the accident and your first doctor visit) and treatment gaps (stopping physical therapy or doctor visits for weeks, then resuming) can hurt your claim. Consistency matters throughout your recovery.

What should I tell the doctor when I go?

Be specific: “I was in a car accident on [date] at [approximate time] and I am experiencing [list all symptoms].” Mention everything, even things that seem minor. This creates the medical record linking your symptoms to the accident.

Varghese Summersett Personal Injury Team

Protect Your Claim. Talk to a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Today.

Insurance companies have teams of adjusters trained to find reasons to pay you less. A gap in treatment hands them exactly what they need.

At Varghese Summersett, we’ve spent years fighting insurance companies on behalf of injured Texans. We know their tactics, and we know how to counter them. Our firm has more than 70 team members across four Texas offices, and our personal injury attorneys have recovered millions for clients, including many who came to us worried that a gap in treatment had ruined their case.

If you’ve been injured in an accident, whether it happened yesterday or weeks ago, call us at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ll give you an honest assessment of your case and explain your options.

Don’t let a gap in treatment cost you the compensation you deserve. Call Varghese Summersett today.

Varghese Summersett

What Is a Gap in Treatment After a Car Accident?

A gap in treatment is any delay between your accident and your first doctor visit, or a pause in your ongoing medical care. Insurance companies use these gaps to argue you weren’t really hurt, and it’s one of the fastest ways to destroy a legitimate personal injury claim.

If you’ve been in a car accident in Texas and haven’t seen a doctor yet, or you stopped going to appointments, your claim may already be losing value by the day. The good news: an experienced personal injury attorney can often help explain or close that gap, but only if you act quickly.

If you’re dealing with a gap in treatment and worried about your claim, call Varghese Summersett at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ve helped thousands of Texans recover compensation even when insurance companies tried to use gaps against them.

Why “I Feel Fine” Is the Most Dangerous Thing You Can Say

Why “I Feel Fine” Is the Most Dangerous Thing You Can Say

You walked away from the crash. You’re sore, maybe a little shaken, but nothing feels broken. You figure you’ll see how you feel in a few days.

This is exactly what insurance companies are counting on.

Here’s what’s actually happening in your body: Immediately after a collision, your system floods with adrenaline and endorphins. This is your “fight or flight” response, and it effectively numbs your pain sensors. You might have a herniated disc, torn ligaments, or even internal bleeding, but your brain won’t register it as pain for 24 to 72 hours.

Soft tissue injuries are particularly deceptive. Whiplash, muscle strains, and ligament tears involve microscopic damage that doesn’t show up on X-rays. As inflammation builds over three to five days, the pain often gets worse, not better. By the time you realize something is seriously wrong, you’ve already created a gap that the insurance adjuster will use against you.

In one recent case, our attorneys represented a client who felt “just stiff” after a rear-end collision on I-30 in Fort Worth. She waited six days to see a doctor. By then, her neck pain had become severe. The insurance company’s first offer was 60% lower than what her injuries warranted, and their adjuster argued repeatedly that she must not have been hurt badly since she didn’t seek immediate care. Our team had to fight significantly harder to recover fair compensation for her, documenting the medical reasons for delayed symptom onset and bringing in expert testimony about soft tissue injury patterns.

The lesson: what feels minor today can become a major problem, both physically and legally.

The Timeline When Insurance Companies Start Cutting Your Claim Value

The Timeline: When Insurance Companies Start Cutting Your Claim Value

There’s no Texas statute that says “your claim loses 40% after two weeks.” But after handling thousands of personal injury cases across Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and throughout Texas, our attorneys have seen clear patterns in how adjusters evaluate gaps.

0 to 72 Hours: The Golden Window

This is considered “immediate” treatment. When you see a doctor within three days of an accident, you create a solid, documented link between the crash and your injuries. Insurance companies have a much harder time disputing causation. Your claim retains its full value.

4 to 7 Days: The Suspicious Zone

Adjusters start asking questions. They’ll check whether you went to work during this time. Did you go to the gym? Post on social media about weekend activities? Even if your delayed treatment was reasonable, expect the insurance company to offer 10 to 20% less than your claim is worth. They’ll argue that if you were really hurt, you would have gone sooner.

8 to 14 Days: The Danger Zone

This is where claims start suffering serious damage. Offers typically drop by 40 to 50%. Adjusters will aggressively argue “intervening causes,” meaning they’ll suggest something else caused your injury during that gap period. Did you lift something heavy? Sleep wrong? Fall? They’ll look for any alternative explanation.

30+ Days: The Deal Breaker

At this point, most insurance adjusters will either deny the injury claim entirely or offer what’s called “nuisance value,” sometimes as little as $500 just to make you go away. They’ll assume, at least publicly, that your injuries are unrelated to the crash. Even legitimate, serious injuries become nearly impossible to recover compensation for once you’ve waited this long without documentation.

How Insurance Adjusters Weaponize Your Gap in Treatment

How Insurance Adjusters Weaponize Your Gap in Treatment

Insurance companies train their adjusters to use gaps strategically. Understanding their playbook helps you see why immediate treatment matters so much.

The “Rational Person” Argument

This is their go-to. The adjuster will argue: “A rational person who is genuinely injured goes to the doctor. You didn’t see a doctor for two weeks. Therefore, you were not injured, or at least not seriously.”

It sounds logical on the surface. Juries sometimes buy it. The problem is that it ignores basic medical reality about delayed symptoms, adrenaline response, and how soft tissue injuries actually work.

The Causation Break

This is the most damaging argument, and the hardest to overcome. To win a personal injury claim in Texas, you must prove that the accident caused your injury. A gap gives the insurance company room to suggest something else did.

Here’s how it plays out: You wait 10 days to see a doctor for back pain. The adjuster responds, “How do we know you didn’t hurt your back lifting groceries on day seven? Or at the gym on day five? Since there’s no medical record from day one, you cannot prove this car accident caused your back pain.”

Without that initial documentation tying your symptoms to the crash, you’re fighting an uphill battle.

Failure to Mitigate Damages

Under Texas law, injured people have a duty to “mitigate” their damages. This means you must take reasonable steps to get better and prevent your injuries from worsening.

If you delay treatment and your condition deteriorates, the insurance company can refuse to pay for that worsening. Their argument: you failed to take care of yourself, so they shouldn’t have to pay for the consequences.

This is particularly brutal with soft tissue injuries. Untreated whiplash can develop into chronic pain. A disc injury that might have healed with early physical therapy can become a surgical case. The insurer will pay for what they claim would have been the outcome with proper treatment, not what actually happened.

What Happens to Your Body After an Accident That You Can’t Feel Yet

What Happens to Your Body After an Accident That You Can’t Feel Yet

Understanding the medical reality helps explain why gaps happen, and why they’re so unfair.

Adrenaline masks your pain. Your body’s stress response suppresses pain signals for hours or even days after trauma. You genuinely feel okay at the scene. That doesn’t mean you are okay.

Inflammation takes time to build. Swelling around injured tissue typically peaks at 48 to 72 hours, not immediately. This is why many accident victims feel worse on day three than they did at the scene.

Internal injuries are silent. Organ damage and internal bleeding don’t always present with dramatic symptoms. Some people have walked around for days with life-threatening internal injuries.

Concussions hide. Traumatic brain injuries often don’t show obvious signs right away. Confusion, headaches, memory problems, and cognitive issues can emerge gradually over days or weeks.

Disc injuries progress. A herniation that feels like mild stiffness today can worsen as it impinges on nerves, eventually causing severe pain, numbness, or weakness in your extremities.

The medical community understands all of this. Insurance adjusters understand it too. They just don’t care, because their job is to pay you as little as possible.
get the compensation you deserve with our personal injury lawyers.

How a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Can Help Close the Gap

Even if you’ve already created a gap, an experienced attorney can sometimes explain it, document it, or minimize its impact. But timing matters.

Controlling the Narrative

Maybe you waited because you don’t have health insurance. Maybe you were afraid of the cost. Maybe you’re a single parent who couldn’t take time off work. Maybe you genuinely thought you were fine until symptoms worsened.

These are valid reasons. But if you don’t document them properly, the insurance company will spin your gap as evidence of fraud or exaggeration. An attorney can help establish a record of why you delayed, so it doesn’t look like you’re making up injuries after the fact.

Letters of Protection

Many people avoid the doctor after an accident because they’re worried about cost. They don’t have health insurance, or they’re afraid of copays and deductibles piling up.

A personal injury attorney can issue what’s called a Letter of Protection (LOP). This is a document that tells the medical provider: treat this patient now, and you’ll be paid out of the eventual settlement. It allows you to get the care you need immediately without paying out of pocket, closing your gap right away.

At Varghese Summersett, we work with a network of medical providers throughout Texas who accept LOPs, ensuring our clients can access treatment regardless of their insurance situation.

Preventing Recorded Statement Mistakes

One of the first things an insurance adjuster will do is ask for a recorded statement. They’ll ask friendly-sounding questions designed to get you to minimize your injuries.

“But you didn’t go to the hospital, so you must have felt okay at the scene, right?”

“You went to work the next day, so the pain couldn’t have been that bad?”

Anything you say can and will be used to reduce your claim. An attorney can handle communications with the insurance company, preventing you from accidentally undermining your own case.

Building the Medical Evidence

Our attorneys work closely with medical professionals to document the connection between your accident and your injuries, even when there’s been a gap. This might include expert testimony explaining delayed symptom onset in soft tissue injuries, medical literature supporting the timeline of your specific injury type, documentation of your symptoms and their progression, and independent medical examinations that establish causation.

This doesn’t guarantee we can overcome a significant gap, but it gives you the best possible chance.

What to Do Right Now If You’ve Been in an Accident

Whether your accident happened today or two weeks ago, here’s what you should do.

If you’re within 72 hours of your accident: Go to urgent care or the emergency room today. Tell the doctor clearly: “I was in a car accident on [date] at [time], and I am experiencing [symptoms].” Be specific and thorough. Mention everything, even symptoms that seem minor. This creates the medical record that protects your claim.

If you’re within one to two weeks: See a doctor immediately. The longer you wait, the more value your claim loses. Even a late record is better than no record.

If it’s been more than two weeks: You still have options, but you need legal help now. Call an attorney before seeing the doctor so they can help you document the gap appropriately.

Regardless of timing: Do not give a recorded statement to the insurance company without talking to an attorney first. Follow through on every medical referral. If the doctor recommends imaging, physical therapy, or specialist evaluation, do it. Don’t skip appointments. Missed visits show up in medical records, and adjusters will find them. Document your symptoms daily. Keep notes on your pain levels, limitations, and how your injuries affect your daily life.

CTA: Injured? We can help.

What Happens After You Call Varghese Summersett

We understand that dealing with injuries, medical bills, and insurance companies is overwhelming. Here’s what to expect when you reach out to our team.

During your free consultation, we’ll review the details of your accident, your injuries, and any treatment you’ve received (or haven’t received). We’ll give you an honest assessment of your case, including how any gap in treatment might affect it.

If we take your case, we handle everything: communicating with insurance companies, connecting you with medical providers who accept Letters of Protection, gathering evidence, and fighting for the compensation you deserve.

Our personal injury team has recovered millions of dollars for Texas accident victims. We have offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake, and we handle cases throughout the state.

Frequently Asked Question

Frequently Asked Questions About Gaps in Treatment

How long is too long to wait to see a doctor after a car accident?

Ideally, you should seek medical attention within 72 hours. After one week, your claim starts losing value. After two weeks, you’ll face significant challenges. After 30 days, most insurers will deny or severely devalue your claim. However, even with a gap, an attorney may be able to help. Call us for a free consultation to discuss your specific situation.

What if I couldn’t afford to see a doctor after my accident?

This is common, and it’s a valid reason for delay. A personal injury attorney can issue a Letter of Protection that allows you to receive treatment now and pay later out of your settlement. Don’t let cost keep you from getting the care and documentation you need.

Can I still file a claim if I have a gap in treatment?

Yes, but your claim will be harder to prove and likely worth less than it would have been with immediate treatment. An experienced attorney can help document the reasons for your gap and build the strongest possible case given the circumstances.

What counts as a “gap” in treatment?

Both an initial delay (time between the accident and your first doctor visit) and treatment gaps (stopping physical therapy or doctor visits for weeks, then resuming) can hurt your claim. Consistency matters throughout your recovery.

What should I tell the doctor when I go?

Be specific: “I was in a car accident on [date] at [approximate time] and I am experiencing [list all symptoms].” Mention everything, even things that seem minor. This creates the medical record linking your symptoms to the accident.

Talk to a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Today

Protect Your Claim. Talk to a Texas Personal Injury Attorney Today.

Insurance companies have teams of adjusters trained to find reasons to pay you less. A gap in treatment hands them exactly what they need.

At Varghese Summersett, we’ve spent years fighting insurance companies on behalf of injured Texans. We know their tactics, and we know how to counter them. Our firm has more than 70 team members across four Texas offices, and our personal injury attorneys have recovered millions for clients, including many who came to us worried that a gap in treatment had ruined their case.

If you’ve been injured in an accident, whether it happened yesterday or weeks ago, call us at (817) 203-2220 for a free consultation. We’ll give you an honest assessment of your case and explain your options.

Don’t let a gap in treatment cost you the compensation you deserve. Call Varghese Summersett today.

Varghese Summersett

You can now leave an anonymous Google review using a nickname instead of your real name. If you’ve wanted to share your experience with Varghese Summersett but hesitated because of privacy concerns, this guide shows you exactly how to leave a Google review without your name attached.

Can You Leave an Anonymous Google Review?

Yes. As of November 2025, Google allows users to leave an anonymous Google review by creating a custom display name and profile picture. This means you can post a review as “Satisfied Client” or any pseudonym you choose instead of your legal name.

Technically, this is pseudonymity rather than full anonymity. Google still connects your review to your account internally. But the public, including friends, family, employers, and anyone searching your name, will only see the nickname you selected. Your real identity stays private.

Why Google Now Allows Anonymous Reviews

Google recognized that many people with genuine experiences were staying silent because they didn’t want their name publicly attached to certain services. This was especially true for people who used attorneys, doctors, therapists, and other professionals in sensitive fields.

The anonymous review feature solves this problem. You can now share honest feedback and help others find good representation without broadcasting your personal legal matters to the world.

how to leave an anonymous reivew

How to Leave an Anonymous Google Review

Follow these steps to set up your custom display name before leaving an anonymous review on Google.

Step 1: Open Google Maps

Open the Google Maps app on your phone or visit maps.google.com on your computer. Make sure you’re signed into the Google account you want to use for the review.

Step 2: Access Your Profile

Tap your profile picture or initial in the top right corner. Select “Your profile” from the menu that appears.

Step 3: Edit Your Profile Settings

Tap “Edit profile” to access your public profile settings. Look for the option labeled “Use a custom name and picture for posting.”

Step 4: Create Your Alias

Toggle on the custom name option. Enter the display name you want to appear on your reviews. This can be a nickname, initials, or something generic like “Texas Client” or “Fort Worth Resident.” You can also choose a different profile picture or avatar.

Step 5: Save and Leave Your Review

Save your changes. Now search for “Varghese Summersett” in Google Maps, select our business profile, and tap “Write a review.” Your review will appear under your chosen alias, not your real name.

What If You Don’t See the Alias Option?

Google announced this feature in November 2025 and is rolling it out gradually. If you don’t see the “Use a custom name and picture for posting” toggle yet, try these steps:

First, make sure your Google Maps app is updated to the latest version. Check the App Store or Google Play Store for updates. Second, try accessing your profile through the Google Maps website on a computer, as some features appear there before the mobile app. Third, wait a few days and check again. Google typically completes major feature rollouts within a few weeks.

Do Anonymous Google Reviews Still Count?

Absolutely. Anonymous Google reviews carry the same weight as reviews posted under real names. Google’s search algorithm doesn’t penalize pseudonymous reviews, and they contribute equally to a business’s overall rating and visibility.

Your review still goes through Google’s normal verification and spam detection systems. The only difference is what the public sees when they read it.

Your Privacy Matters to Us

We understand that hiring an attorney often involves private, stressful situations. Whether you worked with us on a criminal case, a divorce, a custody matter, or an injury claim, we recognize that you may not want those details publicly connected to your name.

That’s why we’re sharing this guide. If you had a positive experience with our team and want to help others find quality legal representation, we’d be grateful for your review. But we also respect that your privacy comes first. The alias option gives you a way to do both.

How to Leave a Review for Varghese Summersett

Ready to share your experience? Click the link for the office location where you worked with our team:

These links take you directly to the review form. Choose your star rating and write about your experience. If you’ve already set up an alias using the steps above, your review will automatically appear under that name instead of your real name.

Not sure what to write? A helpful review might mention which attorney you worked with, what type of case you had (in general terms), how the team communicated with you, and whether you’d recommend our firm to others in similar situations.

Frequently Asked Questions About Anonymous Google Reviews

How do I leave an anonymous Google review?

Open Google Maps, go to your profile, tap “Edit profile,” and enable “Use a custom name and picture for posting.” Choose a nickname and avatar. Then find the business you want to review and leave your feedback. Your review will appear under your chosen name instead of your real name.

Can Google still see my real identity if I leave an anonymous review?

Yes. Google maintains the connection between your review and your real Google account internally. This helps them prevent spam and enforce their policies. However, the public only sees your chosen display name and picture.

Will my old reviews change to show my alias?

Yes. When you enable a custom display name, it applies to all your public contributions on Google Maps, including past reviews. If you previously left reviews under your real name and later add an alias, those older reviews will update to show your new display name.

Can businesses see my real name behind an anonymous Google review?

No. Businesses only see what the public sees: your display name and profile picture. They cannot access your real identity through Google’s review system.

Is leaving an anonymous Google review against the rules?

No. Google explicitly introduced this feature in November 2025 to give users more privacy control. Leaving an anonymous Google review using a pseudonym is now a supported, official option.

Can I change my alias later?

Yes. You can update your custom display name at any time through your Google Maps profile settings. Any changes will apply to all your past and future reviews.

Thank You for Considering a Review

Online reviews help people facing difficult situations find attorneys they can trust. If Varghese Summersett helped you through a challenging time, leaving a Google review can make a real difference for someone else going through something similar.

If you have questions about this process or anything else, our team is always here to help. Call us at (817) 203-2220 or reach out through our website.

Varghese Summersett

How Business Valuation Works in Texas Divorce Cases

Business valuation in divorce determines what your company is worth so the court can divide marital assets fairly. If you or your spouse owns a business, that ownership interest will likely be subject to division, and getting the valuation right can mean the difference between keeping your company intact or watching years of hard work get split unfairly.

At Varghese Summersett, our family law attorneys have handled complex property divisions involving businesses ranging from single-member LLCs to multi-million dollar enterprises. We understand that your business isn’t just an asset on a spreadsheet. It’s your livelihood, your legacy, and often your family’s primary source of income.

Is Your Business Community or Separate Property in Texas

Is Your Business Community or Separate Property in Texas?

Before anyone can value your business, the court must first decide how much of it belongs to the marriage. Texas is a community property state , which means most assets acquired during the marriage belong equally to both spouses, regardless of whose name is on the paperwork.

Under Texas Family Code § 3.003 , property owned before marriage is separate property. But here’s where it gets complicated: if your separate property business increased in value during the marriage because of your time, effort, and skill, that growth may be considered community property.

Texas courts call this “active appreciation.” If you worked 60-hour weeks building your company while your spouse managed the household and raised your children, the value you created through that effort likely belongs to both of you.

On the other hand, “passive appreciation” stays separate. If your business grew simply because the market improved or your industry expanded, that increase typically remains yours alone.

Questions That Determine Characterization

Courts look at several factors when deciding how to characterize a business:

  • When did you start or acquire the business? A company started before marriage is separate property at its core.
  • What was the business worth on your wedding day? This baseline matters tremendously.
  • How was growth funded? If community income was reinvested into a separate property business, some of that value may now be community property.
  • Did your spouse contribute? Contributions don’t have to be direct. A spouse who handled all domestic responsibilities so you could focus on the business may have a claim to the appreciation.

What Valuation Standard Do Texas Courts Use?

What Valuation Standard Do Texas Courts Use?

Texas divorce courts use “fair market value” as the standard for valuing businesses. This means the price a hypothetical willing buyer would pay a hypothetical willing seller in an arm’s length transaction, where neither party is under pressure to buy or sell.

This standard matters because it’s different from “investment value,” which considers what the business is worth to you specifically. Your company might be worth more to you because of your relationships, your skills, or your plans for the future. But the court doesn’t care about that. They want to know what a stranger would pay for it.

The Discount Debate

One of the most contested issues in business valuation is whether to apply discounts for lack of marketability or lack of control. The spouse who owns the business usually argues for these discounts because they lower the value. The non-owning spouse argues against them.

In a 2023 Tarrant County case, our attorneys represented a business owner whose spouse’s expert applied no discounts whatsoever, inflating the company’s value. By presenting credible expert testimony on appropriate minority interest and marketability discounts, we helped our client reach a settlement that reflected the business’s actual worth in the real world, not a theoretical maximum.

The Three Methods for Valuing a Business in Divorce

The Three Methods for Valuing a Business in Divorce

Business appraisers typically use one or more of three approaches to determine fair market value. Understanding these methods helps you evaluate whether the valuation in your case makes sense.

The Asset Approach

The asset approach values a business by adding up everything it owns and subtracting everything it owes. Think of it as a snapshot of the balance sheet. This method works well for companies that hold significant tangible assets, like real estate investment firms or equipment rental companies.

For service businesses or professional practices, the asset approach often produces a “floor value” that underestimates what the company is actually worth. A successful law firm or medical practice might have minimal hard assets but generate substantial income.

The Market Approach

The market approach looks at what similar businesses have sold for recently. Appraisers find comparable companies and adjust for differences in size, risk, location, and industry conditions.

This approach works best when good comparable data exists. For common business types like restaurants, dental practices, or HVAC companies, industry databases often provide useful benchmarks. For unique or niche businesses, finding true comparables can be challenging.

The Income Approach

The income approach values a business based on its ability to generate money. Appraisers look at historical earnings, normalize them to remove one-time events or owner perks, and then apply a multiplier or discount rate to arrive at present value.

For small to mid-size Texas businesses, appraisers frequently use a capitalization multiple applied to normalized EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) or seller’s discretionary earnings.

This approach often produces the highest valuations for profitable businesses, which is why the owning spouse’s expert may prefer asset-based methods while the non-owning spouse’s expert gravitates toward income methods.

Active vs. Passive Appreciation_ Why It Matters

Active vs. Passive Appreciation: Why It Matters

Understanding the difference between active and passive appreciation can significantly impact your divorce settlement.

Active appreciation is value growth you caused through your efforts. This includes management decisions, marketing initiatives, capital investments, hiring talented employees, and simply showing up and working hard. Texas courts generally treat active appreciation as community property.

Passive appreciation is value growth caused by external forces beyond your control. This includes rising industry multiples, favorable tax law changes, economic booms, and general market conditions. Passive appreciation on separate property typically remains separate.

How Courts Allocate Appreciation

When a separate property business has grown during the marriage, courts must determine how much of that growth came from each source. This usually requires expert testimony and detailed financial analysis.

A common approach establishes the business value at the date of marriage and again at trial. The expert then allocates the increase between active and passive components using both qualitative evidence (what did the owner actually do?) and quantitative modeling (how did similar businesses perform during the same period?).

ey Dates That Affect Your Business Valuation

Key Dates That Affect Your Business Valuation

The date chosen for valuation can dramatically change the result. Texas courts consider several potentially relevant dates:

  • Date of marriage establishes baseline value for separate property businesses
  • Date of separation may be relevant if one spouse stopped contributing to the business
  • Date of service (when divorce papers were filed) sometimes serves as a practical cutoff
  • Date of trial gives the most current picture but may reflect market changes unrelated to either spouse’s efforts

Choosing the right valuation date is a strategic decision. If your business has declined since separation, you may want a later date. If it’s grown substantially, you may prefer an earlier date.

Texas courts have discretion in selecting valuation dates, and the choice often becomes a point of negotiation or litigation.

How Business Value Affects Your Divorce Settlement

How Business Value Affects Your Divorce Settlement

Once the court establishes fair market value for the community portion of a business, several options exist for handling it in the final division.

Offset with Other Assets

The most common approach awards the entire business to the operating spouse and compensates the other spouse with a larger share of other community assets. If the community interest in your business is worth $500,000 and your total community estate is $1.5 million, your spouse might receive the house, retirement accounts, and other assets totaling $750,000 while you keep the business.

Structured Buyout

When other assets aren’t sufficient to offset the business value, courts may order a structured buyout. The operating spouse pays the other spouse their share over time, usually with interest. This arrangement can strain cash flow but allows the business to continue operating.

Sale of the Business

In rare cases, courts approve or order the sale of the business with proceeds divided between the spouses. This is typically a last resort when neither spouse can afford a buyout and the parties cannot agree on other arrangements.

What “Just and Right” Means

Texas law requires courts to divide community property in a manner that is “just and right.” This doesn’t necessarily mean 50/50. Judges consider factors including length of marriage, each spouse’s earning capacity, who was primarily responsible for building the business, and whether either spouse committed fraud or wasted community assets.

The same business valuation can produce different divisions depending on these factors. A spouse who sacrificed career opportunities to support the other’s business may receive more than 50% of the community estate.

Common Business Valuation Disputes in Texas Divorces

Common Business Valuation Disputes in Texas Divorces

Certain issues arise repeatedly in business valuation cases. Knowing what to expect helps you prepare.

Hidden Income and Underreported Earnings

Business owners who control the books may be tempted to minimize reported income before a divorce. Cash-heavy businesses are particularly susceptible. Forensic accountants can analyze bank deposits, lifestyle expenses, and industry benchmarks to uncover discrepancies.

Excessive Owner Compensation

When normalizing earnings, appraisers must determine reasonable compensation for the owner’s services. An owner who pays themselves $500,000 annually for a role that typically commands $200,000 is suppressing the business’s apparent profitability. The excess compensation should be added back when calculating true earnings.

Goodwill: Personal vs. Enterprise

Goodwill is the value of a business beyond its tangible assets. Texas courts distinguish between enterprise goodwill (which attaches to the business itself) and personal goodwill (which depends on a specific individual’s reputation and relationships).

This distinction matters most in professional practices. A physician’s patient relationships may constitute personal goodwill that shouldn’t be divided. But the practice’s location, staff, systems, and reputation independent of any one doctor would be enterprise goodwill subject to division.

Dueling Experts

Each side typically hires their own business appraiser, and the results can vary wildly. We’ve seen cases where one expert valued a company at $2 million while the opposing expert claimed $5 million. The court must weigh the credibility, methodology, and assumptions of each expert.

Having an attorney who understands business valuation and can effectively cross-examine opposing experts is essential in these cases.

What to Do if You're Facing Business Valuation in Your divorce

What to Do If You’re Facing Business Valuation in Your Divorce

Protecting your interests requires proactive steps from the beginning.

Gather financial records early. You’ll need several years of tax returns, financial statements, bank records, contracts, and organizational documents. The more complete your records, the more accurate the valuation.

Understand your business’s true worth. Even before hiring a formal appraiser, you should have a sense of what your company might be worth using industry multiples and comparable sales data.

Choose your experts wisely. A credentialed business appraiser (look for CVA, ASA, or ABV designations) with experience in divorce cases and your specific industry will produce more credible testimony than a generalist.

Be honest with your attorney. If there are skeletons in your financial closet, your lawyer needs to know about them before the other side discovers them through discovery.

Think beyond the valuation number. The final outcome depends not just on what the business is worth but on how the court decides to handle that value in the overall property division.

Frequently Asked Question

Frequently Asked Questions About Business Valuation in Texas Divorce

Can my spouse take half my business in a Texas divorce?

Your spouse cannot literally take half ownership of your business in most cases. However, they are entitled to their share of the community property value of the business. This usually means you keep the business but compensate your spouse through other assets or a buyout.

What if I started my business before we got married?

A business started before marriage is separate property. However, any increase in value caused by your efforts during the marriage may be community property. You’ll need a valuation at both the date of marriage and the present to determine what portion is subject to division.

Do I need a business valuation expert?

For any business worth more than a nominal amount, yes. Texas courts expect credentialed expert testimony for business valuations. While a business owner can testify to value, that testimony typically carries less weight than formal expert analysis.

How long does business valuation take in a divorce?

A thorough business valuation typically takes 4-8 weeks once the appraiser has all necessary documents. Complex businesses with multiple entities, extensive real estate holdings, or disputed characterization issues may take longer.

Can I get alimony based on my spouse’s business income?

Business income can affect spousal maintenance calculations in Texas. However, Texas has strict limits on spousal maintenance, and it’s only available in specific circumstances. The business’s profitability may be more relevant to property division than ongoing support.

Why Choose Varghese Summersett?

Get Help from an Experienced Texas Divorce Attorney

Business valuation in divorce is too complex and consequential to handle without skilled legal guidance. The decisions made during this process will affect your financial future for years, possibly decades.

At Varghese Summersett, our family law team includes attorneys who understand both the legal framework and the financial intricacies of business valuation disputes. We work with top forensic accountants and business appraisers to ensure our clients’ interests are protected.

Whether you’re the business owner trying to preserve what you’ve built or the spouse seeking your fair share of marital assets, we can help you understand your rights and pursue the best possible outcome.

Contact us today at (817) 900-3220 for a free consultation. We serve clients throughout Texas from our offices in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake.

Varghese Summersett

Can You Sue a Public School for Sexual Abuse in Texas?

Yes, you can sue a Texas public school for sexual abuse, but your legal options depend heavily on when the abuse occurred. For abuse happening on or after September 1, 2025, House Bill 4623 created a new state-law cause of action that waives governmental immunity and allows victims to hold school districts directly accountable. For abuse before that date, Texas law generally barred state-law negligence claims against public school districts because of sovereign immunity, though victims could still sue individual employees personally and pursue federal claims under Title IX or 42 U.S.C. § 1983, which carry much higher evidentiary burdens.

This distinction matters enormously. For decades, Texas public schools hid behind sovereign immunity while students suffered at the hands of predatory employees. That changed with HB 4623 , the most significant waiver of governmental immunity for Texas public schools since 1969. If you or your child has experienced sexual abuse at school, understanding these different legal pathways is the first step toward justice.

Understanding Sovereign Immunity and Why These Reforms Matter

Why Sovereign Immunity Made These Cases So Difficult

Sovereign immunity is a legal doctrine that prevents citizens from suing the government without its consent. In Texas, this protection extended to school districts, shielding them from most civil lawsuits regardless of how negligent their conduct might have been.

The practical effect was devastating for abuse victims. A teacher could sexually assault a student, and even if the school district knew about prior complaints, ignored red flags during hiring, or failed to supervise the employee, the district faced no financial consequences. Victims could pursue criminal charges against the individual perpetrator or sue the employee personally, but recovering meaningful compensation from someone without significant assets or insurance proved nearly impossible.

This immunity extended to school administrators and employees through a related doctrine called official immunity, which protected government workers from personal liability for discretionary acts performed within the scope of their employment. Combined, these protections created a system where the institutions best positioned to prevent abuse faced no accountability when they failed to do so.

Legal Options Before September 1, 2025

Legal Options Before September 1, 2025

For sexual abuse that occurred before September 1, 2025, victims generally could not pursue state-law negligence claims against Texas public school districts because governmental immunity shielded those entities from liability. However, federal civil rights claims under Title IX and 42 U.S.C. § 1983 remained available, and state-law intentional tort claims could still be brought against individual employees or against private schools, which were never immune.

Title IX Claims

Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 prohibits sex discrimination in federally funded education programs. Courts have interpreted this to include sexual harassment and abuse by school employees. To hold a school district liable under Title IX, a victim must prove two elements:

Actual Notice: An official with authority to address the situation had actual knowledge of the abuse or substantial risk of abuse. Rumors among staff or complaints to teachers without supervisory authority typically do not satisfy this requirement.

Deliberate Indifference: The school’s response to that knowledge was so deficient that it amounted to deliberate indifference. Courts have described this as a response that was “clearly unreasonable in light of the known circumstances.” Simply being negligent or making poor judgment calls is not enough.

This standard comes from the Supreme Court’s decision in Gebser v. Lago Vista Independent School District, where the Court held that school districts would be liable under Title IX only where an official with corrective authority responded to actual notice so inadequately that the response constituted deliberate indifference. This is a demanding standard that many otherwise meritorious cases cannot meet.

42 U.S.C. § 1983 Claims

Section 1983 allows individuals to sue state actors who violate their constitutional rights. In school abuse cases, victims typically allege violations of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause, which protects bodily integrity.

To succeed against a school district (as opposed to an individual employee) under § 1983, victims must demonstrate that an official policy or custom caused the constitutional violation. This can include inadequate hiring policies, deliberate indifference in training or supervision, or a pattern of ignoring known dangers.

Individual school employees can also be sued under § 1983, but they often assert qualified immunity, which protects government officials from liability unless their conduct violated clearly established constitutional rights. While qualified immunity rarely protects employees who commit sexual abuse themselves, it can shield supervisors or administrators who failed to prevent abuse.

One advantage of § 1983 claims: punitive damages may be available against individual defendants who acted with malice. However, punitive damages cannot be recovered against school districts themselves.

The Harsh Reality of Pre-September 2025 Claims

For families pursuing claims for abuse that occurred before September 1, 2025, the federal options present genuine obstacles. The deliberate indifference standard effectively requires victims to prove the school consciously disregarded a known risk, not merely that they should have done more. Many cases involving clear negligence fail to meet this threshold.

Additionally, damages in successful Title IX cases are limited to compensatory relief. Because sovereign immunity blocked most state-law negligence claims against public school districts, victims often lacked access to the broader state tort remedies that would have been available against non-governmental defendants.
The new legal landscape - September 1, 2025 and after

The New Legal Landscape: September 1, 2025 and After

House Bill 4623, signed by Governor Abbott on June 21, 2025, fundamentally changed the calculus for school abuse cases in Texas. The law created Chapter 118 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, establishing direct liability for public schools and their employees in sexual misconduct cases.

Waiver of Governmental Immunity

Under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 118.006, a public school’s governmental immunity to suit and from liability is waived to the extent of liability created by Chapter 118. This means victims can now sue school districts directly under Texas state law for sexual misconduct and certain reporting failures, a type of direct district liability that was effectively unavailable before.

Abolition of Official Immunity

The same statute provides that professional school employees may not assert official immunity in actions brought under Chapter 118. This removes the shield that previously protected administrators who looked the other way, supervisors who failed to act on complaints, and others whose negligence allowed abuse to continue.

Covered Conduct

Chapter 118 applies to two categories of misconduct:

Sexual Misconduct: Defined by reference to specific Texas Penal Code offenses including § 21.12 (improper relationship between educator and student), § 22.011 (sexual assault), § 22.021 (aggravated sexual assault), § 21.02 (continuous sexual abuse of young child), and numerous other sex offenses.

Failure to Report: Violations of the mandatory reporting requirements under Texas Family Code § 261.101, which requires professionals to report suspected child abuse or neglect within 48 hours.

Standard of Liability

Under § 118.002, a public school is liable when it is “grossly negligent or reckless, or engages in intentional misconduct, in hiring, supervising, or employing a professional school employee” who commits sexual misconduct or fails to report abuse.

This gross negligence standard is more favorable to plaintiffs than the federal deliberate indifference standard. Gross negligence involves an extreme degree of risk, coupled with actual subjective awareness of that risk, but does not require the conscious disregard demanded by deliberate indifference. The distinction is subtle but meaningful in litigation.

Joint and Several Liability

HB 4623 requires that the individual employee who committed the act or omission be named as a defendant alongside the school district. This creates joint and several liability, meaning either the school or the employee (or both) can be held responsible for the full amount of damages awarded.

Damages and Recovery

Prevailing claimants under Chapter 118 must be awarded actual damages in a maximum amount of $500,000 for each claimant. In addition, a party who prevails is entitled to court costs and reasonable and necessary attorney’s fees, which are not counted against the $500,000 cap. Exemplary (punitive) damages are not available under Chapter 118, reflecting a legislative compromise that limits recovery to capped compensatory damages plus costs and fees.

Statute of Limitations

Sexual abuse claims under Chapter 118 carry a 30-year statute of limitations, reflecting the Legislature’s understanding that many survivors need years or decades to process trauma and come forward.

Comparision: Federal Claims v. State Claims Under HB 4623

Comparison: Federal Claims vs. State Claims Under HB 4623

Issue Before 9/1/2025 (Federal Claims) After 9/1/2025 (Chapter 118)
Can you sue the school district under state law? No (sovereign immunity) Yes (immunity waived)
Standard for district liability Deliberate indifference (high bar) Gross negligence in hiring/supervising
Official immunity for employees? Yes (for discretionary acts) Abolished for covered conduct
Damage cap None under federal law (compensatory damages not capped) $500,000 in actual damages for each claimant, plus uncapped court costs and reasonable attorney’s fees
Punitive damages Available against individuals under § 1983 Not available under Chapter 118
Must name individual employee? Not required Required (joint and several liability)
Attorney’s fees Available if prevailing under federal claims Mandatory if prevailing
Statute of limitations Varies by claim type 30 years for sexual abuse

Who qualifies as a professional school employee

Who Qualifies as a “Professional School Employee”?

Chapter 118 defines “professional school employee” broadly to include superintendents, administrators, teachers, teacher’s aides, counselors, nurses, bus drivers, school board trustees, and any other person employed by a public school whose employment requires certification and the exercise of discretion.

This expansive definition means that liability can extend well beyond the perpetrator to include those who knew or should have known about abuse and failed to act. Principals who ignored complaints, HR directors who failed to conduct proper background checks, and administrators who covered up misconduct can all face personal liability.

How SB 571 works together with HB 4623
How SB 571 Works Together with HB 4623

Senate Bill 571, which also took effect September 1, 2025, works in tandem with HB 4623 by establishing clear reporting requirements and criminal penalties for failures to report. Under SB 571, school employees must report suspected child abuse to external law enforcement within 24 hours, and superintendents must report misconduct to the Texas Education Agency and State Board for Educator Certification within 48 hours.

When school employees violate these reporting requirements and their failure allows abuse to continue, that violation becomes evidence of gross negligence supporting a civil claim under HB 4623. A superintendent who intentionally conceals misconduct faces both criminal prosecution under SB 571 (a state jail felony) and personal civil liability under HB 4623.

Private Schools _ A Different Analysis

Private Schools: A Different Analysis

Private schools were never protected by sovereign immunity and can be sued under traditional state tort law. This means negligence claims, premises liability claims, and other theories have always been available against private institutions. Private school victims may face no damage cap and can potentially recover punitive damages.

What to do if your child has been abused at school

What to Do If Your Child Has Been Abused at School

Document Everything: Preserve any text messages, emails, social media communications, or other evidence. Write down your recollection of events while they are fresh.

Report to Law Enforcement: File a report with local police or the Texas Department of Public Safety. Criminal investigation is separate from civil claims, and a criminal conviction can strengthen your civil case.

Report to Child Protective Services: Contact the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services at 1-800-252-5400 to make a report.

Seek Medical and Mental Health Care: Your child’s wellbeing comes first. Medical records also serve as evidence of the harm caused.

Consult an Attorney Immediately: An experienced school abuse attorney can advise you on the applicable statute of limitations, help preserve evidence, and evaluate which legal theories apply to your situation.

Frequently Asked Question

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue a Texas public school for sexual abuse that happened years ago?

It depends on when the abuse occurred and whom you are suing. For abuse on or after September 1, 2025, Chapter 118 provides a 30-year limitations period for suing public schools and professional school employees for covered sexual misconduct and certain reporting failures. For earlier abuse, sovereign immunity generally bars state-law negligence claims against public school districts, but federal claims under Title IX or § 1983 may still be available, and Texas has eliminated the statute of limitations for certain civil claims against individual perpetrators of sexual assault occurring on or after September 1, 2019.

What if the school didn’t know about the abuse?

For federal claims, the school must have had actual notice of the abuse or risk. For claims under Chapter 118, the question is whether the school was grossly negligent in hiring, supervising, or employing the perpetrator. This could include failing to conduct proper background checks, ignoring warning signs, or creating conditions that facilitated abuse.

Can I still pursue federal claims for abuse after September 1, 2025?

Yes. Federal claims under Title IX and § 1983 remain available regardless of when abuse occurred. For post-September 2025 abuse, you may pursue both state and federal claims, which could be advantageous if seeking damages beyond the $500,000 cap or punitive damages against individuals.

Varghese Summersett Personal Injury Team

Get Help from an Experienced Texas School Abuse Attorney

At Varghese Summersett, we understand that nothing is more devastating than learning your child has been harmed by someone entrusted with their care and safety. Our team of over 70 attorneys and legal professionals has decades of experience holding institutions accountable when they fail to protect children.

We handle school sexual abuse cases across Texas, including in Fort Worth, Dallas, Houston, and Southlake. Our attorneys stay current on the latest legal developments, including the new protections under HB 4623 and SB 571, to ensure our clients have access to every available avenue of recovery.

If your child has been sexually abused at a Texas public school, time matters. Evidence can disappear, memories fade, and statutes of limitations apply. Contact Varghese Summersett today for a free, confidential consultation to discuss your legal options.

Call us at (817) 203-2220 or contact us online. Your child deserves justice, and we are here to help you fight for it.